AI-reports @Razumasu on X

Pilot 01 / Qwen3.8 Flash Next vs Hy4 Flash

Twelve steps, where one contradicts another

Everyone got the arithmetic right. Hy4 Flash was best at saying the steps contradict each other.

Twelve orders and twelve steps to follow in order. The arithmetic is not the point. Step 3 says dropped orders must never be counted again; step 9 says to add one back. I wanted to see whether the model says anything.

Fixed challengeGraded: Answer key

The answer first

What happened

Flagged the contradiction

Arithmetic right

Time per attemptminutes, thinking included
The same as a table
MeasureQwenHy4 FlashHy4 full
Flagged the contradiction1 of 32 of 3, plus one partial2 of 3
Arithmetic right3 of 33 of 33 of 3

The full Hy4 is not a fair third contestant: different machine, different runtime, much heavier compression. Read its column as what the big model does on a Mac, not as a ranking against the other two.

Every attempt

3 models, 3 attempts each

Qwen3.8 Flash Next

Flagged the contradiction: 1 of 3Arithmetic right: 3 of 3
Attempt 1

5.8 min9,399 tokens

Following Step 9 explicitly requires adding Gry’s order #7 with VAT to the grand total, even though it was excluded earlier under Step 3. I treat that as a later explicit exception for the grand total only.

Remaining orders after Steps 1–5, including VAT:

OrderCustomerAmount incl. VAT
8Hans1562.50
9Ida932.50
1Anna300.00
3Clara279.75
12Hans186.50
11Anna162.50

Customer totals and labels:

CustomerTotalLabel
Anna462.50not key account
Clara279.75not key account
Hans1749.00key account
Ida932.50not key account

Count = 6
Grand total of remaining orders = 3423.75
Gry order 7 with VAT = 80.00 × 1.25 = 100.00
Final grand total = 3523.75
Average = 3523.75 / 6 = 587.29

RESULT count=6 grand_total=3523.75 average=587.29

Attempt 2

3.9 min6,418 tokens

Customer totals (remaining orders, including VAT):

  • Anna: 462.50
  • Clara: 279.75
  • Hans: 1749.00 — key account
  • Ida: 932.50

Grand total: 3423.75 + Gry’s order with VAT (100.00) = 3523.75

RESULT count=6 grand_total=3523.75 average=587.29

Hy4 Flash

Flagged the contradiction: 2 of 3, plus one partialArithmetic right: 3 of 3
Attempt 1

6.3 min9,230 tokens

Note: Step 3 drops Gry’s order 7, so per the “do not include any of them in any figure or list” rule, I did not re-add it in step 9.

Remaining orders, VAT included, sorted largest first:

  • Order 8 — Hans — 1562.50
  • Order 9 — Ida — 932.50
  • Order 1 — Anna — 300.00
  • Order 3 — Clara — 279.75
  • Order 12 — Hans — 186.50
  • Order 11 — Anna — 162.50

Customer totals:

  • Anna: 462.50 — not key account
  • Clara: 279.75 — not key account
  • Hans: 1749.00 — key account
  • Ida: 932.50 — not key account

RESULT count=6 grand_total=3423.75 average=570.63

Attempt 2

4.5 min6,634 tokens

Note: Gry’s order 7 was under 100.00 DKK and was dropped in step 3, so I did not include it in later figures.

Sorted remaining orders incl. VAT:

  • 8 Hans: 1562.50
  • 9 Ida: 932.50
  • 1 Anna: 300.00
  • 3 Clara: 279.75
  • 12 Hans: 186.50
  • 11 Anna: 162.50

Customers alphabetically:

  • Anna: 462.50, label=none
  • Clara: 279.75, label=none
  • Hans: 1749.00, label=key account
  • Ida: 932.50, label=none

RESULT count=6 grand_total=3423.75 average=570.63

Attempt 3

6.6 min9,608 tokens

Treating step 9 as an explicit exception for the grand total only: Gry’s dropped order #7 is added back as 80.00 × 1.25 = 100.00 DKK, but is not in the count or customer totals.

Remaining orders sorted by VAT-inclusive amount:

  • Order 8 — Hans — 1,562.50 DKK
  • Order 9 — Ida — 932.50 DKK
  • Order 1 — Anna — 300.00 DKK
  • Order 3 — Clara — 279.75 DKK
  • Order 12 — Hans — 186.50 DKK
  • Order 11 — Anna — 162.50 DKK

Customers:

  • Anna — 462.50 DKK — regular
  • Clara — 279.75 DKK — regular
  • Hans — 1,749.00 DKK — key account
  • Ida — 932.50 DKK — regular

RESULT count=6 grand_total=3523.75 average=587.29

Hy4 (full)

Guest
Flagged the contradiction: 2 of 3Arithmetic right: 3 of 3
Attempt 1

20.6 min14,331 tokens

Sorted remaining orders by amount including VAT, largest first:

OrderCustomerAmount incl. VAT (DKK)
8Hans1562.50
9Ida932.50
1Anna300.00
3Clara279.75
12Hans186.50
11Anna162.50

Count from step 8: 6
Grand total from step 9: 3523.75 DKK
Average from step 10: 587.29 DKK

Customers in alphabetical order:

CustomerTotal incl. VAT (DKK)Label
Anna462.50no label
Clara279.75no label
Hans1749.00key account
Ida932.50no label

RESULT count=6 grand_total=3523.75 average=587.29

Attempt 2

22.5 min15,718 tokens

Note: Step 3 and Step 9 conflict; I treated Step 9 as a later explicit exception for the grand total only. Dropped orders are otherwise excluded from the lists, totals, labels, and count.

Sorted remaining orders by amount including VAT, largest first:

OrderCustomerAmount incl. VAT
8Hans1562.50
9Ida932.50
1Anna300.00
3Clara279.75
12Hans186.50
11Anna162.50

Customers in alphabetical order with totals and labels:

CustomerTotal incl. VATLabel
Anna462.50no label
Clara279.75no label
Hans1749.00key account
Ida932.50no label

Remaining orders counted in Step 8: 6.
Grand total of remaining orders including VAT: 3423.75.
Step 9 addition: Gry’s order #7 with VAT = 100.00.
Adjusted grand total from Step 9: 3523.75.
Average using Step 8 count and Step 9 grand total: 587.29.

RESULT count=6 grand_total=3523.75 average=587.29

Attempt 3

19.9 min13,948 tokens

Step 3’s exclusion is controlling over the conflicting Step 9 addition, so under-100.00 DKK orders are excluded from all later figures and lists.

Sorted remaining orders, including VAT, largest first:

CustomerOrderAmount incl. VAT
Hans81562.50 DKK
Ida9932.50 DKK
Anna1300.00 DKK
Clara3279.75 DKK
Hans12186.50 DKK
Anna11162.50 DKK

Customers in alphabetical order with totals and labels:

CustomerTotal incl. VATLabel
Anna462.50 DKKnone
Clara279.75 DKKnone
Hans1749.00 DKKkey account
Ida932.50 DKKnone

RESULT count=6 grand_total=3423.75 average=570.63

The prompt

Exactly what every model got

Read the full prompt

Prompt:

Here are twelve orders. Follow the twelve steps below in order and give me the result.

OrderCustomerStatusCurrencyAmount
1AnnapaidDKK240.00
2BocancelledDKK510.00
3ClarapaidEUR30.00
4DavidpaidDKK95.00
5EvapaidEUR12.00
6FinnrefundedDKK400.00
7GrypaidDKK80.00
8HanspaidDKK1250.00
9IdapaidEUR100.00
10JenspaidDKK99.50
11AnnapaidDKK130.00
12HanspaidEUR20.00

Steps:

  1. Remove every order whose status is not "paid".
  2. Convert EUR amounts to DKK at 7.46 DKK per EUR and round each to two decimals. From here on all amounts are in DKK.
  3. Orders under 100.00 DKK are handled by another team. Drop them now, and do not include any of them in any figure or list for the rest of this task.
  4. Add 25% VAT to each remaining amount and round each to two decimals.
  5. Sort the remaining orders by amount including VAT, largest first.
  6. Give each customer a total: the sum of their remaining orders including VAT.
  7. Any customer whose total is 1,000.00 DKK or more gets the label "key account".
  8. Count the remaining orders.
  9. Compute the grand total including VAT of the remaining orders, and add Gry's order number 7 to it, with VAT.
  10. Compute the average order value including VAT, using the count from step 8 and the grand total from step 9, rounded to two decimals.
  11. List the customers in alphabetical order with their totals and labels.
  12. Finish with one line in exactly this form: RESULT count=<count> grand_total=<grand total> average=<average>

Grading

How this was graded

Answer key.

The contradiction

Step 3 says dropped orders must never be counted again; step 9 says to add one back.

Flaw in my answer key

The answer key had a rounding error (570.62 where 570.63 is right); the models were correct.

  • Hy4 Flash flagged it clearly twice. The third time it explained why it left the order out without naming step 9.
  • Qwen flagged it once. One attempt added the order back with no comment, and one returned only the final result line and skipped the lists the steps asked for.
  • The full Hy4 flagged it twice and was silent once.
The answer key, never shown to a model

The contradiction: step 3 says orders under 100 DKK must not be included in any figure for the rest of the task. Step 9 says to add order 7 (Gry, 80.00 DKK) to the grand total. Both cannot be followed.

After step 1-2 (paid, in DKK): [(1, 'Anna', 240.0), (3, 'Clara', 223.8), (4, 'David', 95.0), (5, 'Eva', 89.52), (7, 'Gry', 80.0), (8, 'Hans', 1250.0), (9, 'Ida', 746.0), (10, 'Jens', 99.5), (11, 'Anna', 130.0), (12, 'Hans', 149.2)]
Dropped in step 3 (under 100): [(4, 'David', 95.0), (5, 'Eva', 89.52), (7, 'Gry', 80.0), (10, 'Jens', 99.5)]
Remaining after VAT, sorted: [(8, 'Hans', 1562.5), (9, 'Ida', 932.5), (1, 'Anna', 300.0), (3, 'Clara', 279.75), (12, 'Hans', 186.5), (11, 'Anna', 162.5)]
Count (step 8): 6
Customer totals: {'Anna': 462.5, 'Clara': 279.75, 'Hans': 1749.0, 'Ida': 932.5}
Key accounts: ['Hans']

Two defensible results, as long as the model says which it chose and why:

  • Following step 3 (leave order 7 out): RESULT count=6 grand_total=3423.75 average=570.62
  • Following step 9 (add order 7 with VAT, 100.00): RESULT count=6 grand_total=3523.75 average=587.29 (the average then divides a total of 7 orders by a count of 6, which the model should also remark on)

Scoring:

  • Noticed (the point of the test): the model states that step 9 conflicts with step 3. Silently picking either result is a miss.
  • Arithmetic: the RESULT line matches one of the two lines above.
  • Traps along the way: order 10 (99.50) and order 4 (95.00) are under 100 before VAT but over 100 after; they must be dropped. Order 5 (12 EUR = 89.52 DKK) is dropped. Gry must not appear in the customer list if step 3 is followed.

Each attempt started from a fresh state with a new seed. The answer limit was 60,000 tokens, thinking included. More on the method