AI-reports @Razumasu on X

Pilot 01 / Qwen3.8 Flash Next vs Hy4 Flash

Design an office network from a messy customer email

Opinion One plan of nine said no to the budget. I think that was the honest answer.

A physiotherapy clinic is moving into an old bank building and its owner writes a long, messy email asking for a network. The email has a budget that does not quite work and two wishes that conflict. The model answers as the IT consultant.

Fixed challengeGraded: Opinion

The answer first

What happened

Words per plan

Access points proposed

Time per attemptminutes, thinking included
The same as a table
MeasureQwenHy4 FlashHy4 full
Words per planabout 5,0001,600 to 2,3003,200 to 3,800
Access points proposed4 to 124 to 66 to 11

The full Hy4 is not a fair third contestant: different machine, different runtime, much heavier compression. Read its column as what the big model does on a Mac, not as a ranking against the other two.

Every attempt

3 models, 3 attempts each

Tap an attempt to open it.

Qwen3.8 Flash Next

Words per plan: about 5,000Access points proposed: 4 to 12
Attempt 127.2 min43,453 tokens

Subject: Re: netværk?? – first network design for Krogh Fysio (please approve / questions before electrician)

Hi Mette,

Thanks for the details. Below is my first network design for Krogh Fysio. I have written it so you can approve it, and so a technician can use it to build/configure the network.

There are three important points before the technical part:

  1. I do not think you need a new Windows server.
    Since Fysiojournal is cloud-based, the existing Synology can continue as your “server thing” for scanned documents and old journals. We will back it up properly.
  2. 40,000 kr ex moms is realistic for network equipment + my design/configuration/installation, but only if new data cabling/electrician work is NOT included in the 40,000 kr.
    If the 40,000 kr must also include pulling all new Cat6/Cat6A data cables, PoE runs, wall penetrations, old-building work, etc., then it is not realistic. Old building cabling can easily cost more than the network equipment itself.
  3. The “kid printing from the waiting room” and “patient journals” issues are fixed by network segregation.
    Patients will get an isolated guest Wi-Fi network that cannot see clinic PCs, printers, NAS, phones, cameras or payment terminals.

Please read especially the section “What I need you to decide/clarify” because the electrician needs a cable plan soon.


1. Summary of the proposed design

You will have:

  • Separate network areas/VLANs for:
    • staff/laptops/front desk PCs
    • treatment-room tablets
    • patient guest Wi-Fi
    • Telia IP phones
    • alarm cameras
    • printers/card terminals
    • Synology NAS
    • network management
  • 4–5 ceiling/wired Wi-Fi access points, not mesh through thick brick walls.
  • PoE switch for Wi-Fi APs, IP phones and alarm cameras.
  • Existing Synology in the vault/basement as the local file server.
  • Second Synology at your home for offsite backup, with no required monthly subscription.
  • Secure remote access for you from home Thursdays, without opening unnecessary ports to the internet.
  • QoS/prioritisation for Telia phones and treatment tablets.
  • Guest Wi-Fi isolated so patients cannot print to clinic printers or access clinic data.

2. Main assumptions

Please correct these if wrong:

  • Building: ground floor + first floor, approx. 180 m² per floor.
  • Thick brick walls; treatment room 3 currently has poor Wi-Fi.
  • Fibia 1000/1000 fibre enters ground floor near front desk.
  • Vault/basement is where you want the Synology/network rack.
  • Existing Synology currently contains approx. 600 GB of scanned documents and old journals.
  • Fysiojournal is cloud-based.
  • 8 treatment rooms: 5 ground floor, 3 first floor.
  • Each treatment room will have a wall tablet for Fysiojournal.
  • 11 staff now, 14 by summer.
  • 3 front desk fixed PCs.
  • Remaining staff use laptops.
  • 2 normal printers + 1 label printer.
  • 2 Nets card terminals.
  • 6 Telia IP phones.
  • Alarm company will install 4 PoE cameras and needs a network port.
  • Patient Wi-Fi should be available in waiting room.
  • You want offsite backup with no monthly subscription.
  • You work from home Thursdays and need access to the Synology.
  • Physios on home visits write journals from the car/cloud; they do not need local access to the clinic network unless you specifically require that.

3. Physical layout
Basic topology
Internet / Fibia 1G
        |
        v
Fibia ONT/router near front desk
        |
        | 1 required data/fibre link to vault
        | 1 recommended spare link
        v
Vault / basement rack
  - Firewall/router/UniFi Dream Machine or equivalent
  - Main PoE switch
  - Synology NAS
  - UPS
        |
        +--------------------------------------------+
        |                   |                        |
        v                   v                        v
Wi-Fi access points   Telia IP phones           Alarm cameras
(PoE)                 (PoE)                     (PoE)
        |
        +--------------------------------------------+
        |                   |                        |
        v                   v                        v
Front desk PCs        Printers/card terminals     Treatment tablets
Staff laptops/laptops via Wi-Fi/Ethernet          via Wi-Fi/Ethernet
Rack/cabinet placement

I propose two areas:

  1. Ground floor network box near Fibia entry/front desk
    • Fibia ONT/router
    • Patch panel or wall cabinet
    • Optional small UPS for Fibia equipment
    • Optional access switch if needed for front desk/devices
  2. Vault/basement rack
    • Firewall/router
    • Main 24-port PoE switch
    • Synology NAS
    • UPS
    • Patch panel for all cables

Important: the vault can only be used for the NAS/network equipment if there is acceptable ventilation and temperature. A sealed basement vault with no ventilation can become too warm for Synology, switch and especially UPS batteries. If the vault is hot or unventilated, we may need to place the rack in a different ventilated cupboard or add cooling. I need to check this.


4. IP/VLAN addressing plan

This is a practical address plan for a small clinic. The technician can implement it directly.

VLAN and subnet table
VLANPurposeSubnetGatewayDHCP rangeLeaseNotes
10Network management192.168.10.0/24192.168.10.1NonePermanentFirewall, switches, AP management
20Staff / laptops / PCs192.168.20.0/24192.168.20.1.100–.2208 hoursStaff devices, front desk PCs
30Treatment-room tablets192.168.30.0/24192.168.30.1.100–.13024 hoursTablets in 8 treatment rooms
40Patient/guest Wi-Fi192.168.40.0/24192.168.40.1.100–.2402 hoursIsolated from clinic network
50Telia IP phones192.168.50.0/24192.168.50.1.100–.1507 daysPhones may need Telia-specific DHCP/VLAN
60Alarm cameras192.168.60.0/24192.168.60.1.100–.1307 daysAlarm company equipment
70Printers / card terminals / UPS mgmt192.168.70.0/24192.168.70.1.100–.150PermanentStatic IPs preferred
80Synology NAS / server192.168.80.0/24192.168.80.1NonePermanentMain NAS in vault
90VPN / remote work172.20.90.0/24172.20.90.1.100–.15024 hoursOr Tailscale/WireGuard range depending on method

All subnets are /24 unless later changed.


Static IP assignments / DHCP reservations

Use static IP or DHCP reservation for these.

DeviceVLANIPNote
Firewall/router LAN gateway10192.168.10.1
Core/vault switch management10192.168.10.11
Ground floor access switch10192.168.10.12If used
First floor access switch10192.168.10.13If used
AP-GF-01 waiting/front desk10 management IP192.168.10.21
AP-GF-02 ground corridor10 management IP192.168.10.22
AP-GF-03 treatment room 3 area10 management IP192.168.10.23
AP-FF-01 first floor corridor10 management IP192.168.10.24
AP-FF-02 first floor far end10 management IP192.168.10.25Optional/recommended
Main Synology NAS80192.168.80.81Vault
Backup Synology at homeVPN/TailscaleAssigned by VPNHome
Front desk PC 120192.168.20.21Reservation
Front desk PC 220192.168.20.22Reservation
Front desk PC 320192.168.20.23Reservation
Treatment tablet room 130192.168.30.31Reservation
Treatment tablet room 230192.168.30.32Reservation
Treatment tablet room 330192.168.30.33Reservation
Treatment tablet room 430192.168.30.34Reservation
Treatment tablet room 530192.168.30.35Reservation
Treatment tablet room 630192.168.30.36Reservation
Treatment tablet room 730192.168.30.37Reservation
Treatment tablet room 830192.168.30.38Reservation
Telia phone 1–650.101–.106If Telia allows
Printer 170192.168.70.71Static IP
Printer 270192.168.70.72Static IP
Label printer70192.168.70.73Static IP
Nets card terminal 170192.168.70.74Static IP / MAC reservation
Nets card terminal 270192.168.70.75Static IP / MAC reservation
UPS management70192.168.70.76If network-managed
Alarm camera 160192.168.60.61If alarm company requires static
Alarm camera 260192.168.60.62
Alarm camera 360192.168.60.63
Alarm camera 460192.168.60.64

Note: Telia phones sometimes have special VLAN or DHCP requirements. If so, we may need to coordinate with Telia and adjust VLAN 50 slightly.


5. Switch port configuration for the technician

The technician should create port profiles/policies like this. If using UniFi, these are network profiles; if using TP-Link/MikroTik, equivalent VLAN profiles.

General principles
  • Uplink switch-to-switch/firewall: trunk, carrying VLANs 10, 20, 30, 40, 50, 60, 70, 80.
  • Wi-Fi AP port: trunk or AP profile with mapped SSIDs/VLANs.
  • Standalone IP phone: untagged/access VLAN 50, PoE.
  • IP phone + PC behind the phone: phone receives tagged VLAN 50; PC receives untagged VLAN 20.
  • Treatment tablet wired port: untagged VLAN 30.
  • Front desk PC port: untagged VLAN 20.
  • Printer/card terminal port: untagged VLAN 70.
  • Alarm camera port: untagged VLAN 60, PoE.
  • NAS port: untagged VLAN 80.
  • Guest Wi-Fi: SSID mapped to VLAN 40, client isolation enabled, block clinic subnets.
  • Management VLAN 10: no normal staff access; management only via admin device/VPN.
SSID to VLAN mapping
SSIDVLANSecurityUse
KroghFysio Staff20WPA2/WPA3 or WPA2-Enterprise laterStaff laptops/PCs
KroghFysio Treatment30WPA2/WPA3, restrictedTreatment tablets
KroghFysio Guest40WPA3 or WPA2/WPA3 mixed, isolatedPatients
Hidden management/control SSID10Disabled or hiddenOnly for setup if needed

For tablets that may not support the newest WPA3 mode, use WPA2/WPA3 mixed temporarily, but do not disable security.


6. Provisional cable drop schedule for the electrician

Please send this to the electrician as a starting point, but hold final cable counts until I receive a floor plan.

Cable type
  • Cat6 minimum, Cat6A recommended for PoE and future-proofing.
  • Terminate RJ45.
  • Label every cable.
  • Keep network cable away from strong lighting dimmers/motors where possible.
  • Maximum copper run: approx. 100 metres. If longer, use fibre between cabinets.
  • For PoE, use proper Cat6/Cat6A and quality patch panels.
Provisional drops
Location / itemDropsPoE?PurposeCabinet/switch
Fibia entry to vault2No1 WAN/uplink required, 1 spare recommendedGF → Vault
Wi-Fi APs5YesGF waiting, GF corridor, GF treatment 3, FF corridor, FF far endGF/FF/Vault
Front desk PCs3No3 fixed PCsGF/Vault
Telia phones not combined with PC3–6Yes6 phones total; front desk may share PC drops if phones have PC pass-throughGF/FF/Vault
Treatment-room tablets, if wired/PoE8Yes if PoEOne per treatment roomGF/FF/Vault
Printers2NoNormal printersGF/FF/Vault
Label printer1NoLabel printerGF/Vault
Nets card terminals2NoPayment terminalsGF/Vault
Alarm cameras4YesAlarm company camerasGF/FF/Vault
Synology NAS1NoVault rackVault
Spare drops2–4MixedFuture printers/phones/tablesWherever possible
Rough total
  • If tablets are Wi-Fi only and phones can partly share PC ports: approx. 23–28 drops.
  • If tablets need their own network cable/PoE and phones need separate drops: approx. 34–38 drops.

If the electrician cannot do that many, priority should be:

  1. Fibia WAN/uplink to vault
  2. Alarm cameras
  3. Nets card terminals
  4. Telia phones
  5. Wi-Fi APs
  6. Treatment tablets if wired
  7. Printers/label printer
  8. Front desk PCs
  9. Spare drops

I strongly recommend asking the electrician to leave at least a couple of spare pulls/conduit if the old building allows it. In old buildings, future changes are usually harder than today.


7. Wi-Fi design
Main approach

With thick brick walls, mesh Wi-Fi usually performs poorly unless mesh nodes have wired backhaul. Therefore I recommend wired access points with wired backhaul, not wireless mesh.

Recommended AP placement

Minimum: 4 APs.
Recommended: 5 APs if budget allows, because old brick walls and multiple treatment rooms can kill signal.

Ground floor:

  1. AP-GF-01: near front desk/waiting room.
    • Patient guest Wi-Fi
    • Staff Wi-Fi
    • Treatment tablets ground floor
  2. AP-GF-02: central ground-floor corridor/treatment area.
    • Staff Wi-Fi
    • Treatment tablets
  3. AP-GF-03: treatment room 3 or directly outside treatment room 3.
    • This is the AP specifically to fix the known treatment room 3 problem.

First floor:

  1. AP-FF-01: central first-floor corridor/near stairs.
    • Staff Wi-Fi
    • Treatment tablets
    • Guest if you want guest coverage upstairs too
  2. AP-FF-02: far end of first floor / additional treatment room coverage.
    • Optional but recommended

No Wi-Fi AP is needed inside the vault if there is no need for wireless there. The vault door may reduce Wi-Fi anyway.

Guest Wi-Fi issue

You said patients should have Wi-Fi in the waiting room.

There is a physical limitation:

I cannot make Wi-Fi perfectly exist only in the waiting room. Radio waves leak through walls, and patients may receive the signal elsewhere.

What we can do:

  • Put the guest SSID on the waiting/front-desk AP only if you accept that patients lose Wi-Fi if they walk into other rooms.
  • Or broadcast the guest SSID across the clinic but isolate it so it cannot reach clinic devices.
  • Set bandwidth limit so guests do not consume all bandwidth.
  • Enable client isolation so patients cannot print to clinic printers.

My recommendation is the second option: guest Wi-Fi available but isolated. If you want it strictly waiting-room-only, we can configure it on selected APs, but roaming will be worse.

Treatment tablets

For treatment tablets I recommend either:

  • Wired VLAN 30 port in each treatment room, or
  • Wi-Fi SSID “KroghFysio Treatment” mapped to VLAN 30.

If the wall tablets have Ethernet, wired is better for stability. If they need PoE, the electrician should know in advance.


8. Security design
VLANs/firewall rules

Default: deny between VLANs unless specifically allowed.

Staff VLAN 20

Allowed:

  • Internet.
  • Fysiojournal cloud.
  • NAS VLAN 80 for files if needed.
  • Printer VLAN 70 for printing.
  • Label printer if needed.
  • No management access to switches/firewall unless Mette/admin device specifically allowed.
Treatment tablet VLAN 30

Allowed:

  • Internet/HTTPS to Fysiojournal.
  • Label printer if required.
  • Possibly normal printer if clinically required.

Blocked:

  • Staff PCs.
  • NAS.
  • Phones.
  • Cameras.
  • Network management.
  • Printing from other VLANs.
Patient/guest VLAN 40

Allowed:

  • Internet only.

Blocked:

  • All clinic VLANs.
  • Clinic printers.
  • NAS.
  • Phones.
  • Cameras.
  • Payment terminals.
  • Network devices.

Enabled:

  • Client isolation.
  • Short DHCP lease.
  • Bandwidth limitation.
Telia IP phones VLAN 50

Allowed:

  • Telia SIP/SBC/cloud.
  • Internet for phone updates if required.
  • Low latency/QoS.

Blocked:

  • Staff devices.
  • NAS.
  • Cameras.
  • Payment terminals.
  • Guest VLAN.
Alarm cameras VLAN 60

Allowed:

  • Internet to alarm company cloud if required.
  • Allowed communication between camera and alarm NVR/cloud as required.

Blocked:

  • Clinic LAN.
  • Staff devices.
  • Guest VLAN.
  • Inbound internet access.
Printers/card terminals VLAN 70

Allowed:

  • Internet 443 if card terminals or printers need cloud services.
  • Staff/tablets can print via IP.
  • Card terminal communication with Nets/cloud only as needed.

Blocked:

  • Guest VLAN.
  • Treatment tablets unless specifically needed.
  • General inbound access.
NAS VLAN 80

Allowed:

  • Staff access to needed file services.
  • Backup traffic to home backup NAS.
  • Tailscale/WireGuard access.

Blocked:

  • Direct internet access except update/backup/VPN.
  • Guest access.
  • Tablets unless specifically needed.

9. QoS/prioritisation

We should prioritise:

  1. Telia IP phones – DSCP EF or equivalent.
  2. Treatment tablets – high priority for Fysiojournal.
  3. Staff PCs/laptops – normal/high.
  4. Backup traffic – medium, can run outside busy hours.
  5. Guest Wi-Fi – low, rate-limited.

This helps avoid phone calls or treatment tablets becoming choppy if someone streams video or does a large backup.


10. Backup design: no monthly subscription

You want proper backup not in the building, but no more monthly subscriptions. That is possible, but with some limitations. I will explain honestly.

Proposed backup design
  1. Primary Synology in vault:
    • Contains scanned documents and old journals.
    • Should be in RAID1/SHR with at least two healthy disks.
    • Use Btrfs if possible so we can use snapshots.
    • Daily snapshots.
    • Encryption if required for sensitive data.
  2. Secondary Synology at your home:
    • Offsite backup target.
    • Same Synology ecosystem.
    • No monthly service fee.
    • Receive backup over secure VPN/Tailscale from the primary NAS.
    • Keep versioned backups.
  3. Backup schedule
    • Nightly incremental backup from vault NAS to home NAS.
    • Retention:
      • 30 daily versions
      • weekly versions for several weeks/months
      • monthly long-term versions if disk space allows
    • Email alerts for failed backup.
  4. Initial seeding
    • First backup of 600 GB will take time.
    • If home internet is fast, it can run over the internet.
    • If home internet is slower, we can first back up to a temporary USB disk, then take that disk to your home and use it to seed the initial backup. Subsequent backups can be incremental.
  5. Manual cold copy
    • Optionally, once per month copy to an encrypted USB disk and store it outside your home, for example with Jonas/accountants, if allowed.
    • This is not automatic, but it adds protection without a monthly subscription.
  6. Monthly restore test
    • I would test a restore at least monthly or quarterly.
    • A backup you have never restored is not a proven backup.
Honest limitation

A proper professional offsite backup service usually costs monthly money and gives better management, alerts, retention and resilience.

I can meet your “no monthly subscription” requirement by using a second Synology at your home, but then:

  • if your home internet is down, backup cannot run;
  • if your home power is down, backup cannot run;
  • if your home NAS dies at the same time as the vault NAS, you need recovery effort;
  • it is better than the USB disk Friday method, but it is not the same as a managed business backup service.

If you want a guaranteed offsite backup with full professional retention, a small monthly cost is practically unavoidable.


11. Remote work from home
Mette, home Thursdays

You need access to Synology from home.

Recommended:

  • Use WireGuard VPN on the firewall/router if Fibia provides a usable public IPv4 address.
  • If Fibia uses CGNAT or port forwarding is difficult, use Tailscale.
  • Or use Synology QuickConnect with 2FA, but I prefer Tailscale/WireGuard as the first choice for a cleaner isolated network.

This gives you secure access to:

  • Synology DSM
  • Synology Files/Drive if configured
  • Internal services needed from home

Do not expose DSM, SMB shares or network printers directly to the internet.

Physios on home visits

They do not need access to the clinic network just to write journals from the car if Fysiojournal is cloud-based.

They should use:

  • Mobile internet/phone hotspot/4G/5G, or
  • Their home/mobile network,
  • Then directly connect to Fysiojournal in a browser/app.

No clinic VPN is required unless they need local files or internal services.

Important no-subscription limitation

Tailscale can often be done without monthly cost for a small number of remote users. But if you later need many users permanently connected to the clinic network, remote access may require a paid plan or more complex configuration.

For now:

  • Mette home access: fine.
  • Technician support access during installation: fine temporarily.
  • Many staff permanently connected from home: would need discussion and could involve cost.

12. Equipment to buy and rough costs

All prices below are rough estimates ex moms and can change. I am choosing business/SMB-grade equipment, not consumer stuff.

Recommended equipment
ItemQtyRough cost ex momsNotes
Firewall/router/controller, e.g. Ubiquiti UDM-SE or equivalent pfSense/OPNsense box12,500–3,800 krHandles VLANs, firewall, Wi-Fi management, VPN
Main PoE+ switch, 24 ports, high PoE budget12,800–4,500 krFor APs, phones, cameras
Optional access switch near front desk/first floor1800–2,000 krDepends on final cabling layout
Wi-Fi access points, PoE, e.g. U6-Pro/U6-LR or TP-Link Omada EAP670 class4–51,300–1,800 kr each = 5,200–9,000 kr4 minimum, 5 recommended
Existing Synology health check/disk/memory upgrade10–3,000 krIf existing NAS is healthy, can be 0
Backup Synology, e.g. DS224+13,200–4,000 krFor your home
2×4 TB NAS hard disks21,300–1,800 kr total or per setDepends on brand
UPS for NAS/router/switch11,800–3,000 krSize depends on PoE load; if many PoE devices, may need larger UPS
19" rack/wall cabinet1–2800–2,500 krVault + possibly GF cabinet
Patch panels, SFP modules, patch leads, labels—1,500–3,000 kr
Design, configuration, installation, testing, documentation—9,000–13,500 krApprox. 12–16 hours depending on devices/coordination
Total budget estimate excluding electrician data cabling
  • Low end: approx. 29,000–33,000 kr ex moms
  • Realistic with 5 APs and some contingency: approx. 37,000–45,000 kr ex moms

To stay at 40,000 kr ex moms, we should assume:

  • existing Synology is reusable and healthy;
  • data cabling is not included in the 40,000 kr;
  • 4–5 APs only;
  • no major new UPS capacity;
  • Telia phones and alarm cameras work with standard VLAN/PoE;
  • no unexpected Fibia bridge/IP problems;
  • no need to replace existing Synology disks.
Electrician/data cabling estimate

For old-building data cabling, I would expect roughly:

  • 800–1,800 kr per data point depending on how difficult the routes are.
  • If you need 25–35 points, that can become 20,000–60,000 kr ex moms before equipment.

So again: if 40,000 kr includes all new data cabling, it is not realistic.


13. What cannot be done exactly as requested

I want to be straightforward.

1. Patient Wi-Fi strictly only in waiting room

I cannot guarantee that patient Wi-Fi will be physically limited only to the waiting room. Radio waves leak.

We can:

  • enable guest Wi-Fi only on the waiting-room AP;
  • use bandwidth limits;
  • isolate guest clients;
  • block access to clinic printers and data.

But if a patient walks near another AP, they may still receive the signal. If you want that absolutely controlled, it would require more specific wireless engineering or acceptance that roaming/drops happen.

2. Proper offsite backup with zero monthly subscription and zero compromise

We can do it to your home NAS with no monthly service fee, but it is not equivalent to a managed cloud backup service. It depends on your home internet/power and is less robust.

If you require guaranteed offsite backup with professional retention, a small monthly cost is usually needed.

3. 40,000 kr if it includes all electrician/data cabling

If 40,000 kr must pay for both the network equipment/my work and all new cable pulling/termination in the old building, then no, I do not think that is realistic.

4. Vault placement if no ventilation

If the vault is unventilated and becomes warm, I cannot safely put the NAS and UPS there. Heat will shorten equipment life and can cause failures. We would need ventilation, a different rack location, or a smaller/less heat-generating setup.

5. Telia/alarm company/Nets special requirements

If Telia phones, alarm cameras or Nets terminals require special VLANs, static routing, public IP rules or their own cloud configuration, we may need to coordinate with them. That is possible, but if they require something unusual, it can add time/cost.


14. What I need from you before the electrician starts

Please confirm/answer these. The most urgent ones are for the electrician.

A. Building/floor plan

Please send:

  • a floor plan with treatment room numbers 1–8;
  • where the Fibia fibre comes in;
  • where the front desk is;
  • where the vault stairs/vault door are;
  • where you imagine the vault rack/communications cabinet;
  • where the 4 alarm cameras should be placed;
  • where the APs should go if you have preferences;
  • where each printer, label printer and Nets card terminal will be;
  • where the 6 phones will be;
  • whether there is a possible first-floor communications cupboard.
B. Electrician scope

Please clarify:

  • Is data cabling included in the 40,000 kr budget?
  • Is the electrician cost separate?
  • Does the building already have usable Cat5/Cat6/Cat7 data cabling?
  • Can the electrician pull Cat6A?
  • Can the electrician run two links from Fibia entry to vault?
  • Can the electrician install PoE-rated Cat6/Cat6A properly?
  • Are there power outlets near the vault rack and GF Fibia cabinet?
  • Is the vault temperature/ventilation acceptable for NAS/UPS?
C. Fibia

Please ask Fibia or confirm:

  • Fibia router model.
  • Can the Fibia router be used as bridge/modem only?
  • Can you disable the Fibia Wi-Fi?
  • Is the public IPv4 static or dynamic?
  • Is Fibia using CGNAT?
  • Is IPv6 available?
  • Do you need Fibia TV or another service that forces you to keep their Wi-Fi/router active?

If Fibia cannot be bridged, we can work around it, but configuration becomes less clean.

D. Telia IP phones

Please provide:

  • exact phone model, for example Yealink/Snom model number;
  • where the 6 phones will be;
  • whether the phones have a PC pass-through port;
  • whether Telia requires a specific VLAN;
  • whether you want to keep all existing phone numbers;
  • contact person at Telia/accounting provider.

I need to make sure phones work after the move.

E. Alarm company

Please provide:

  • alarm company contact;
  • camera model;
  • whether they use an NVR or cloud;
  • exact camera locations;
  • whether they need 4 PoE ports from your switch;
  • whether they bring their own switch;
  • what they need from the network: DHCP, static IPs, internet access, VLAN, port forwarding, cloud outbound access.

They said “need a port and PoE”. We can provide that, but I need details.

F. Synology

Please provide:

  • Synology model;
  • current disks: size, model, age;
  • RAID/SHR type;
  • used/free capacity;
  • whether it supports Btrfs;
  • any disk errors/SMART warnings;
  • whether you want to keep disks and replace them soon.

If the existing Synology is healthy, we reuse it as primary. If not, we may need to budget disks or a replacement.

G. Treatment tablets

Please provide:

  • tablet model;
  • how they connect: Wi-Fi only, Ethernet, or Ethernet+PoE;
  • whether they support WPA3;
  • whether they need local printing;
  • whether they need access to Synology;
  • how they are powered: wall adapter, PoE adapter, etc.

This affects cable drops.

H. Printers and card terminals

Please provide:

  • model of printer 1;
  • model of printer 2;
  • model of label printer;
  • whether each has Ethernet;
  • whether any are USB-only;
  • exact placement;
  • Nets card terminal model;
  • whether Nets requires static IP/MAC address or specific network setup.
I. Backup location

Please decide:

  • Can the second Synology be at your home?
  • Do you have home internet/router access?
  • Would you prefer backup to a trusted offsite location, e.g. Jonas/accountants?
  • How long do old journals/scanned documents need to be retained?
  • Is monthly manual USB copy to Jonas/accountants acceptable as an extra cold copy?
J. Staff and user access

Please clarify:

  • Do you have a Microsoft domain or Microsoft 365/Azure AD/Entra ID?
  • Do you want local Windows accounts, or cloud identity?
  • Who needs Synology access: everyone, only Mette/front desk, only Jonas?
  • Should staff access old scanned journals from Synology, or only Fysiojournal cloud?

I do not recommend building a new local Active Directory unless you already have one. It adds complexity and cost.

K. Guest Wi-Fi

Please choose:

  1. Guest Wi-Fi only on the waiting/front-desk AP, knowing patients may lose it if they move, or
  2. Guest Wi-Fi throughout the clinic but isolated from clinic network.

Also choose:

  • simple shared guest password, or
  • guest portal with daily password/vouchers.

15. What I recommend you do next

Please do this:

  1. Send me a floor plan or even a simple hand-drawn plan.
  2. Mark:
    • Fibia entry
    • front desk
    • treatment rooms 1–8
    • printers
    • card terminals
    • phones
    • alarm camera positions
    • possible AP positions
    • vault rack location
  3. Tell me whether the electrician/data cabling is inside the 40,000 kr budget.
  4. Send existing Synology details.
  5. Send Telia phone and alarm company details.
  6. Tell me whether the tablets need Ethernet/PoE.
  7. Confirm whether backup to your home Synology is acceptable.

Once you answer those, I will produce a final approval version:

  • final cable drop list for the electrician;
  • final equipment list;
  • final fixed/semi-fixed budget;
  • VLAN/Wi-Fi/firewall configuration plan;
  • backup plan;
  • installation schedule before 1 February.

Best regards,
Mads
IT consultant

Attempt 222.7 min36,379 tokens

Subject: Re: netværk?? – Proposed network design, cable plan, and budget

Hi Mette,

Thanks — this is exactly the kind of information I need. You are right to want to sort this before the electrician starts. Below is a design you can approve and that a technician can build from. I have tried to keep it practical, but still safe for patient data.

The short answer:

  • Yes, we can stop the patient’s kid printing from the waiting room. The patient Wi-Fi must be on a separate network segment and printers must be on the staff network, not the patient network.
  • The old bank building with thick brick walls needs a serious Wi-Fi plan. I would not rely on a few central Wi-Fi boxes. I would plan for one access point in or immediately outside each treatment room, plus one in the waiting area.
  • The Synology can live in the vault, but only if there is a proper wired cable route into the vault and power there. Wi-Fi will not work through a steel door.
  • A backup that leaves the building with no monthly subscription is only possible if you own/control a second device outside the building — for example a second Synology at your home or at the accountant’s office. If you do not want to do that, then either you need a small paid cloud backup service or you accept a manual USB-disk solution, which is not “proper” backup.
  • Budget: 40,000 DKK ex moms is tight but realistic for the core network if:

    • your electrician installs/pulls the cables,
    • the alarm company supplies the cameras,
    • Telia/Nets equipment is not bought by us,
    • we reuse the existing Synology,
    • and we use mid-range Wi-Fi equipment.

    If I must also buy cable material, UPS units, cabinets, and a second backup NAS at home, we will be around 38,000–44,000 DKK ex moms, depending on choices.


1. Overall design

The basic idea is: one secure internal clinic network, plus completely separated networks for patient Wi-Fi, treatment tablets, IP phones, cameras, and card terminals.

Internet / Fibia 1000/1000
        |
        v
Fibia ONT/router, ideally bridged
        |
        v
Main router/firewall/controller at ground floor cabinet
        |
        +-----------------------------+
        |                             |
Ground floor PoE switch        First-floor PoE switch
        |                             |
        + Vault/basement switch       + Wi-Fi APs, future desks,
        |                                printers, phones
        + Synology NAS in vault
        |
        + PoE switches also feed:
            - Wi-Fi access points
            - Telia IP phones
            - alarm cameras
            - card terminals, printers where wired

I recommend a UniFi-based build because it can be done without mandatory monthly subscription. If you prefer a more enterprise-grade firewall, a Fortinet FortiGate is also possible, but it may add 1,500–2,500 DKK or more and make setup slightly more complex.


2. Physical layout and cable plan for the electrician

This is the part the electrician needs before week 3.

Recommended cabinet locations

I recommend three small cabinet/patch locations:

  1. Ground floor cabinet near Fibia entry/front desk
    Here: Fibia entry, main router/firewall, core patch panel, ground-floor switch.
  2. First-floor cabinet
    Ideally above the ground-floor cabinet, or as close as possible to the same wall/service shaft.
    Here: first-floor switch, patch panel, UPS if possible.
  3. Vault/basement cabinet
    Here: Synology, small switch, patch panel, UPS.
    No Wi-Fi. Only wired network.

If the vault is not physically suitable because there is no power, ventilation, or cable path, we should move the Synology to a secure cabinet on one of the two floors instead. A locked steel vault sounds good, but a NAS still needs electricity, airflow, and network.


3. Baseline cable plan

Baseline assumption: Cat6a cables for access points, PCs, printers, cameras, card terminals, uplinks, and spares. Cat6a is sensible because it supports 10 Gbit over distance and avoids re-cabling later.

Summary for electrician

Baseline: 34 Cat6a cable runs, including uplinks and spares.

If you need to save money, the minimum useful version is around 29–30 runs. The optional savings are listed below.


Detailed cable list
Cable IDWhereCable / purposePoE?Notes
WAN-01Fibia outlet to ground cabinet1 Cat6aNoFibia to router/firewall.
GF-UPL-FF-1 to 3Ground cabinet to first-floor cabinet3 Cat6aNoUplink. One can be active now, others can be spares or link aggregation later.
GF-UPL-VLT-1 to 2Ground cabinet to vault cabinet2 Cat6aNoAt least one active. Two preferred for redundancy/spare.
GF-AP-01 to GF-AP-05Ground treatment rooms 1–55 Cat6a PoEYesOne AP per treatment room.
GF-AP-06Waiting room1 Cat6a PoEYesPatient Wi-Fi and general coverage.
GF-FD-01 to GF-FD-03Front desk, 3 PC positions3 Cat6aNoOne per fixed PC/phone position if Telia phones support pass-through. If not, we may need more; need phone models.
GF-PAY-01 to GF-PAY-02Checkout/card terminal positions2 Cat6aNoNets terminals should be wired and isolated.
GF-PRT-01Ground printer1 Cat6aNoPrinter should be wired. Disable Wi-Fi Direct if possible.
GF-LBL-01Label printer1 Cat6aNoCan be removed if label printer is USB only and not shared on network.
CAM-01 to CAM-04Alarm company camera positions4 Cat6a PoEYesAlarm company tells us exact locations. We supply PoE/network; they configure cameras.
FF-AP-01 to FF-AP-03First-floor treatment rooms 6–83 Cat6a PoEYesOne AP per treatment room.
FF-AP-04First-floor common/office/stairwell1 Cat6a PoEYesCoverage and staff Wi-Fi upstairs.
FF-DESK-01 to FF-DESK-03First-floor future fixed desks/PCs3 Cat6aNoCan be removed if you are confident laptops/Wi-Fi are enough.
FF-PRT-01First-floor printer1 Cat6aNoWired printer.
VLT-NAS-01Vault, Synology/NAS position1 Cat6aNoNetwork port at NAS position.
SPARE-GF-01Ground common area1 Cat6aNoFuture AP or desk.
SPARE-FF-01First-floor common area1 Cat6aNoFuture AP or desk.

Total baseline: 34 Cat6a runs.

Minimum version if you want to save: remove the 3 first-floor future desk runs, the label printer run, and one spare, leaving 29. But I would not reduce AP runs.


4. Patch panel / cabinet suggestion

To make this buildable, I suggest:

  • Ground cabinet: 24-port patch panel, wall cabinet or small rack.
  • First-floor cabinet: 24-port patch panel, wall cabinet.
  • Vault cabinet: 8- or 12-port patch panel, wall cabinet.

The technician will label every cable, for example:

GF-AP-01 Treatment Room 1
GF-FD-01 Front desk PC 1
GF-PAY-01 Card terminal 1
FF-AP-03 Treatment Room 8
VLT-NAS-01 Synology

5. Network addressing and VLAN plan

We will not put everything on one flat network. Flat networks are exactly how a guest can print or access the Synology.

I suggest a private range: 10.10.0.0/16, with VLANs.

VLANNameSubnetGatewayDHCP rangePurpose
10Management10.10.10.0/2410.10.10.1NoneSwitches, access points, UPS management, firewall admin.
20Clinic LAN10.10.20.0/2310.10.20.110.10.20.50–10.10.21.119Staff laptops, front desk PCs, printers, Synology access.
30Treatment tablets10.10.30.0/2410.10.30.110.10.30.50–10.10.30.200Wall tablets using Fysiojournal cloud. No LAN access.
50Guest/patient Wi-Fi10.10.50.0/2310.10.50.110.10.50.50–10.10.51.199Patients in waiting room. Internet only.
60VoIP / Telia phones10.10.60.0/2410.10.60.1Depends on TeliaTelia IP phones.
70Alarm cameras10.10.70.0/2410.10.70.1None or limited static4 cameras. Isolated.
80Payment / Nets terminals10.10.80.0/2410.10.80.1StaticCard terminals. Isolated.
Static IP suggestions
DeviceVLANStatic IPNotes
Ground switch1010.10.10.11Managed switch.
First-floor switch1010.10.10.12Managed switch.
Vault switch1010.10.10.13If needed.
Ground UPS1010.10.10.21
First-floor UPS1010.10.10.22If used.
Vault UPS1010.10.10.23
Synology2010.10.20.50Main file server/NAS.
Camera 1–47010.10.70.31–34Confirm with alarm company.
Nets terminal 1–28010.10.80.20–21Confirm with Nets.

The technician should trunk these VLANs on the inter-switch links:

VLAN 10, 20, 30, 50, 60, 70, 80

6. Wi-Fi design
SSIDs
SSID exampleVLANAccessNotes
Krogh-Clinic20StaffLaptops, front desk PCs, Synology, staff printing. WPA3/WPA2-AES.
Krogh-Clinical30Treatment tablets onlyTablets. Access to Fysiojournal cloud, not clinic LAN. Optional MAC filtering.
Krogh-Patient50PatientsGuest Wi-Fi. Internet only. Client isolation. No LAN access.

No Wi-Fi should be used for:

  • Synology,
  • card terminals if avoidable,
  • Telia IP phones,
  • alarm cameras.

Those should be wired where possible.

Access point placement

For 180 m² per floor with thick brick walls, I would plan:

  • 1 AP in or immediately outside each treatment room: 8 APs.
  • 1 AP in waiting room: 1 AP.
  • 1 AP in a common/office/stairwell area: 1 AP.

Total: 10 APs as baseline.

If treatment room 3 still has poor coverage because of brick, the solution is not “turn up the power on one AP.” The solution is to add or move an AP so the room has a dedicated access point. That may mean adding one or two APs after a site survey.

For patient Wi-Fi in the waiting room:

  • It gets internet access only.
  • It cannot see clinic PCs.
  • It cannot see printers.
  • It cannot see Synology.
  • It cannot see card terminals.
  • Devices should not be able to talk to each other.
  • Bandwidth can be limited so a patient does not slow down the clinic network.

I would recommend bandwidth limiting such as 10–20 Mbit per patient device unless you need guest Wi-Fi for other reasons.


7. Security design
What will be separated

We will create firewall rules so that:

  • Patient Wi-Fi cannot reach the clinic LAN.
  • Treatment tablets cannot reach the clinic LAN or Synology.
  • Treatment tablets can reach Fysiojournal over HTTPS only, if possible. If Fysiojournal cannot give a domain/IP list, tablets may need broader internet access but still no LAN access.
  • Alarm cameras cannot access clinic LAN.
  • Cameras cannot be reached from patient Wi-Fi.
  • Card terminals can reach Nets/payment endpoints but cannot be accessed from clinic LAN unless Nets explicitly requires it.
  • VoIP phones can reach Telia, but not the Synology or patient data.
  • Synology can be reached by staff LAN and by Mette’s VPN, but not directly from the internet.
Basic rules I will implement
SourceDestinationAction
Clinic LANInternetAllow
Clinic LANSynologyAllow
Clinic LANManagement VLANAllow only admin access
Treatment tabletsInternetAllow
Treatment tabletsClinic LANDeny
Treatment tabletsSynologyDeny unless Fysiojournal vendor proves it is required
Guest/patient Wi-FiInternetAllow
Guest/patient Wi-FiPrivate clinic rangesDeny
Guest/patient Wi-FiPrintersDeny
CamerasInternet only if alarm company requiresAllow to specific alarm endpoints
CamerasClinic LANDeny
Payment terminalsNets endpointsAllow
Payment terminalsClinic LANDeny unless required by Nets
VoIPTelia SIP/RTP endpointsAllow
VoIPClinic LANDeny
Important: vendor information needed

For the stricter rules, I need technical contact details or endpoint lists from:

  • Fysiojournal,
  • Nets card terminals,
  • Telia IP phones,
  • Alarm company cameras.

Without those lists, we can still block LAN access, but we may not be able to make the rules as narrow as best practice.


8. Printing, card terminals, Telia phones, and cameras
Printing

The patient-printing problem is solved by:

  1. Printers go on the clinic LAN, VLAN 20.
  2. Patient Wi-Fi is VLAN 50.
  3. Guest VLAN cannot reach VLAN 20.
  4. Disable or secure AirPrint/Wi-Fi Direct/IPP if possible.
  5. Do not connect printers to patient Wi-Fi.
Label printer

If the label printer is just for one PC, USB may be fine. If multiple staff need it, it should be on clinic LAN.

Nets card terminals

Best practice:

  • Wire the terminals.
  • Put them on VLAN 80.
  • Allow only outbound traffic to Nets/payment endpoints.
  • Block inbound and lateral access.
  • Do not put card terminals on patient Wi-Fi.
  • Do not put card terminals on the same VLAN as normal PCs unless Nets says it is acceptable.

If the terminal is wireless, it needs its own isolated SSID and VLAN. I need to know the exact terminal models.

Telia IP phones

Telia IP phones need:

  • PoE from switch,
  • VoIP VLAN 60,
  • QoS/priority,
  • correct SIP configuration,
  • Telia’s cooperation.

This must be coordinated with Telia. I cannot guarantee the phones will keep working until I know:

  • model,
  • whether they currently use a Telia router,
  • whether they can be placed behind our firewall,
  • MAC addresses if Telia requires them,
  • VLAN/SIP configuration from Telia.

If Telia says their phones must be behind a Telia box, we can still design around that, but it may be slightly less elegant.

Alarm cameras

The alarm company saying “port and PoE” is normal. We can provide:

  • PoE ports on a switch,
  • isolated VLAN 70,
  • no access from patient or clinic LAN.

We need from them:

  • camera models,
  • PoE power type,
  • exact camera locations,
  • IP requirements,
  • whether cameras record locally or to their cloud,
  • who configures the cameras.

We provide the network. They configure the alarm system.


9. Synology and backup
Synology in vault

The existing Synology can remain your central file server for scanned documents and old journals.

It should have:

  • static IP 10.10.20.50,
  • wired 1 Gbit connection,
  • UPS power,
  • good ventilation,
  • no direct internet exposure.

I recommend not using QuickConnect as your normal remote-access method. It can be useful for emergencies, but it bypasses some of the firewall control we are building.

Backup target outside the building

You want:

proper backup that is not in the building, but no monthly subscription.

This is possible, but only in a specific way:

Option A: second Synology outside the building — recommended if no subscription

For example:

  • second Synology at your home, or
  • second Synology at the accountant’s office, or
  • another always-on NAS/device outside the clinic.

We configure Hyper Backup from the clinic Synology to the remote device.

Requirements:

  • remote device must be reachable,
  • connection encrypted,
  • backup encrypted,
  • someone responsible for checking it,
  • remote device must have enough capacity and uptime.

Estimated hardware if needed:

  • second Synology 2-bay: approx. 1,800–2,500 DKK ex moms,
  • two 4 TB HDDs: approx. 1,000–1,800 DKK ex moms.

Your current data is about 600 GB, but with backup versions and retention I would recommend at least 2 TB, preferably 4 TB, at the remote side.

Option B: paid cloud backup

This is usually the easiest professional option.

Examples: Synology C2, Backblaze B2, TeraCloud, or similar.
But you said no subscriptions. If you later reconsider, expect roughly 100–300 DKK/month depending on provider and retention.

Option C: USB disk rotation

This is not ideal, but better than nothing. You already have Lars taking a USB disk home. If this is the only no-subscription option, we must make it much more disciplined:

  • encrypted USB disk,
  • daily/weekly schedule,
  • verification/checksum,
  • log of who took which disk,
  • monthly restore test,
  • disk health checks.

But if you mean “proper backup” in the sense of reliable, monitored, encrypted, automatically verified offsite backup, then no subscription requires a second site/device outside the building.

If you have neither a home NAS nor a cloud backup subscription, then the request “proper backup not in the building with no monthly cost” cannot be done reliably.

Backup retention plan

For the Synology data, I would aim for:

  • daily incremental backups,
  • 30-day retention,
  • 12 monthly full/long-term retention,
  • checksum verification,
  • email alerts for failures,
  • quarterly restore test.

If backup goes to your home over internet, the initial full backup may take many hours. Options:

  • schedule it over nights,
  • or temporarily take the second NAS to the clinic, do the initial backup locally, then take it home.

That is practical and avoids waiting for a full 600 GB backup over a slow connection.


10. Remote work
Your Thursday home work

For access to Synology from home:

  • Use a VPN from your laptop to the clinic.
  • No port forwarding from the internet to the Synology.
  • Route VPN access to the clinic LAN/Synology as narrowly as possible.
  • Use a strong VPN key/password and ideally MFA if the chosen firewall supports it without paid license.
  • Use DNS filtering, firmware updates, strong admin passwords.

A major uncertainty is Fibia.

If Fibia can:

  • bridge their router, or
  • give the firewall a public IP, or
  • forward traffic,

then a normal clinic VPN works well.

If Fibia uses CGNAT and will not allow bridging/public IP, incoming VPN may not work normally. Then options are:

  • Fibia paid public IP/static IP,
  • QuickConnect as a compromise,
  • a cloud relay service with possible subscription,
  • or a different internet provider/product.

I cannot guarantee remote access until we know what Fibia allows.

Home visits / car journaling

The two physios doing home visits should not need a clinic VPN just to use Fysiojournal, because Fysiojournal is cloud-based.

For them:

  • tablets/laptops use their normal 4G/5G data,
  • access Fysiojournal over HTTPS,
  • do not store journals locally,
  • enforce device lock,
  • use MFA on Fysiojournal if available,
  • use official tablet/app,
  • if a tablet is lost, it should be disabled in Fysiojournal and wiped remotely if possible.

If they use clinic Wi-Fi in treatment rooms, they should be on the treatment-tablet VLAN, not the patient VLAN.


11. QoS and performance

With 1000/1000 Fibia, the network itself is fast enough. The important part is making sure clinical use is not slowed by guests or Wi-Fi issues.

Priority:

  1. VoIP phones,
  2. Fysiojournal tablets,
  3. clinic PCs/Synology,
  4. patient Wi-Fi.

For patient Wi-Fi, I would rate-limit total bandwidth, for example 50–100 Mbit total or 10–20 Mbit per client. You can adjust later.

For Wi-Fi:

  • use 5 GHz where possible,
  • avoid interference,
  • use ceiling mount where possible,
  • do not hide APs behind furniture,
  • do not use one AP “through several brick walls.”

12. Equipment list and rough cost

Prices are approximate, DKK, excluding VAT (ex moms). Exact prices depend on distributor and current offers.

Recommended baseline equipment
ItemQtyApprox. costNotes
UniFi UDM-Pro SE or equivalent router/firewall/controller13,300No mandatory monthly. 1 Gbit WAN; Fibia 1000/1000 is 1 Gbit.
24-port PoE+ switch12,800–3,500Ground/vault core or first floor depending on layout.
16- or 24-port PoE+ switch12,000–3,000Second floor or ground access.
Small switch for vault1400–800If not covered by another PoE switch.
UniFi U6-Lite/U6+ access points108,000–12,000Thick walls likely need the better models.
UPS units, line-interactive, 750–1500 VA32,000–3,000Fibia/router/ground switch, vault Synology, first-floor switch.
Wall cabinets/racks, patch panels, faceplates, patch leads, labelslot2,500–4,000Ground, first floor, vault.
Cat6a cable/conduit if not supplied by electricianlot2,500–6,000If electrician supplies cable, this can be 0 or small.
Design, configuration, VLANs, firewall, Wi-Fi, VPN, backup setup, documentation, traininglot7,500–9,000My time.
Budget estimate
ScopeApprox. ex moms
Minimum viable build, electrician supplies cable, lower-end APs, no extra backup NAS28,000–34,000
Recommended build with UPS, cabinets, 10 decent APs, configuration34,000–40,000
Recommended build plus second Synology backup NAS and drives37,000–43,000
Fortinet firewall option instead of UniFi+1,000–2,500

So 40,000 DKK ex moms is realistic but tight. It is realistic if the cable material and electrician labour are outside this budget, and if we reuse existing Synology/Telia phones. If I also need to buy everything including cable, cabinets, UPS units, and a home backup NAS, we may land near 42,000 DKK.


13. What cannot be done exactly as requested

You asked for some things that have practical limits:

“Backup not in the building, but no monthly subscriptions”

This can be done only if:

  • you have a second NAS/device outside the building, or
  • you accept a manual encrypted USB disk routine.

If you do not have a remote device and do not want any subscription, then proper automated offsite backup is not possible in a reliable way.

“Server in the vault”

Possible only if there is:

  • power,
  • ventilation,
  • network cable route,
  • secure cabinet,
  • UPS.

Wi-Fi will not work in the vault through a steel door. The Synology must be wired.

If the electrician cannot run a proper cable into the vault, we should not put the Synology there.

“Remote access from home”

Possible if Fibia allows proper routing/VPN. If Fibia uses NAT/CGNAT and cannot be bridged or given a public IP, standard incoming VPN may not work. Then we need another remote-access method, possibly with small cost or compromise.

“Patient must not be able to print”

This can and will be prevented by VLAN/firewall separation. If a printer has Wi-Fi Direct or open AirPrint features enabled, we must disable or restrict them.

“Alarm company says port and PoE”

We can provide that. But we will not put alarm cameras on the patient network, and we will not give them free access to clinic LAN. The alarm company must configure their own equipment.

“Card terminals must keep working”

We can isolate them, but I need Nets technical requirements. If Nets says they need special network configuration, we must follow that while still isolating as much as possible.

“Telia phones must keep working”

We can support IP phones, but Telia must cooperate. I need phone models and their configuration requirements.


14. Decisions I need from you before ordering/building

Please answer these as far as you can.

A. Electrician and building
  1. Can you send a floor plan, even a simple drawing or photo of the plan?
    Needed for AP locations and cable routes.
  2. Can the electrician pull 34 Cat6a runs as baseline?
    If not, which runs can be reduced?
  3. Is there a clean cable route from the Fibia/front-desk area down to the vault?
    Important: cable must not have to pass through the steel door.
  4. Does the vault have:
    • power,
    • ventilation,
    • enough airflow if the door stays closed,
    • room for a Synology and UPS,
    • safe physical locking?
  5. Are there existing network cables that can be reused or tested?
  6. Can the first-floor cabinet be placed above or near the ground-floor cabinet?
    This makes uplinks much simpler.
B. Fibia
  1. Is the Fibia router supplied by Fibia, and do you have admin access?
  2. Can Fibia bridge the router or put it in DMZ behind our firewall?
  3. Do you have a public IP, or are you behind CGNAT?
  4. If Fibia requires their router to remain in control, do you accept a less ideal setup, or do you want to investigate a Fibia public IP/static IP option?
C. Telia IP phones
  1. What exact Telia phone models do you have?
  2. Are the phones currently plugged into a Telia router or into your normal network?
  3. Can you ask Telia for:
    • VLAN support,
    • SIP settings,
    • whether they need MAC addresses,
    • whether they can work behind our firewall?
D. Nets card terminals
  1. How many terminals will you have at the new place?
  2. Will the terminals use Ethernet or Wi-Fi?
  3. Can you get Nets technical contact or endpoint list for firewall rules?
E. Alarm company
  1. What camera models will the alarm company install?
  2. Where exactly will the 4 cameras be?
  3. Do the cameras need local NVR or cloud recording?
  4. Does the alarm company need remote access? If yes, how do they do it today?
F. Fysiojournal tablets
  1. What tablet model will be used in treatment rooms?
  2. Can the tablets use Ethernet, or will they be Wi-Fi only?
  3. Where will tablets be mounted, and where does their power/charging come from?
  4. Do tablets need to print, or only use Fysiojournal cloud?
  5. Can Fysiojournal give domains/IP ranges so tablets can be locked down to only Fysiojournal traffic?
G. Synology and backup
  1. What Synology model is it, and what DSM version?
  2. Is the RAID/SHR healthy?
  3. Do you have admin credentials?
  4. Do you have or want a second Synology/device outside the building for backup?
  5. If yes: home or accountant’s office? Who is responsible for the remote device?
  6. If no: do you accept a manual encrypted USB disk backup, or do you want to reconsider a small paid cloud backup?
H. Budget scope
  1. Does your 40,000 DKK include:
    • electrician labour,
    • cable material,
    • alarm cameras,
    • Telia phone cost,
    • Nets terminal cost,
    • second backup NAS?

If you are expecting 40,000 DKK to include all of those, that is not realistic. If it includes network design, core network equipment, Wi-Fi, switches, router/firewall, UPS, basic cabinets, and my configuration time, then it is tight but possible.


15. What I will deliver if approved

If you approve the design and budget, I will provide and implement:

  1. Network diagram.
  2. VLAN/IP table.
  3. Cable plan for electrician.
  4. Switch port plan.
  5. Firewall rules.
  6. Wi-Fi SSIDs and VLANs.
  7. Guest isolation.
  8. Payment terminal isolation.
  9. VoIP VLAN and QoS.
  10. Camera isolation.
  11. VPN for your home access, if Fibia allows.
  12. Synology network settings and Hyper Backup configuration.
  13. Basic security hardening.
  14. Documentation and short training for Lars or your responsible person.

I will not include long-term log retention, paid cloud security subscriptions, alarm-company camera licensing, phone purchases, or Nets terminal licensing unless we agree separately.


16. My recommendation

If you want to approve a practical version, I would do this:

  1. Approve the 34-run cable baseline, or minimum 29 runs if tight.
  2. Confirm Fibia can be bridged or put into DMZ.
  3. Confirm whether Synology can physically and electrically work in the vault.
  4. Choose backup option:
    • best no-subscription option: second Synology outside the building,
    • fallback: encrypted USB disk routine with strict process.
  5. Get technical details from Telia, Nets, alarm company, and Fysiojournal.
  6. Then I can give final fixed price and start configuration.

Please reply with your answers or as many as you have now. If you want, I can also do a short site visit before the electrician starts, especially to check the vault cable route and wall thickness/Wi-Fi layout.

Best regards,
IT consultant

Attempt 324.8 min39,709 tokens

Subject: RE: netværk?? – Proposed network design for Krogh Fysio

Hi Mette,

Thanks for the details – this is exactly the information I need. I’ll answer in English, as Jonas suggested.

Below is a proposed design you can approve and a technician can use as a build specification. There are a few important reality checks first, especially around budget, backup, and the Telia/Nets/alarm systems.


1. Key message before the details
Budget: 40,000 kr ex moms

Possible – but only under specific assumptions.

I can aim for around 40,000 kr ex moms for:

  • Network equipment and configuration
  • Wi-Fi design and APs
  • VLANs/security
  • Migration and documentation
  • A simple offsite backup using a second NAS at home/another business

But only if the electrician’s cabling is quoted and paid separately.

If 40,000 kr must include structured cabling for two floors, backbones, ceiling access, power work, rack, UPS, backup, and all labour, then 40,000 kr is not realistic. With two floors, old brick walls, treatment rooms, cameras, phones, printers, card terminals, backup, and patient data, a realistic all-in budget would be more like 60,000–90,000 kr ex moms, depending on cabling and whether you want enterprise-grade firewall/UTM features.

Backup with no monthly subscriptions

You asked for backup outside the building but no more subscriptions.

A proper managed offsite backup normally has a monthly cost.
There is no good “backup service” with zero recurring cost.

Your realistic choices are:

Backup optionMonthly costRisk levelRecommendation
Managed cloud backup in EU~50–150 kr/monthLowBest for reliability, offsite, ransomware protection
Second Synology/NAS at home or another business0 kr/month, but ~5,000–7,500 kr one-timeMediumAcceptable if you accept less monitoring and less “service”
Encrypted USB drives rotated weekly to another location0 kr/monthHighI would not recommend this for patient data unless you accept the risk

If you insist on no subscription, I would recommend one-time purchase of a second NAS placed at your home or another trusted business location, with encrypted Hyper Backup over VPN. But I cannot certify that as fully robust as a managed backup service.


2. Current problems and how the new design fixes them
Problem: Patient’s child printed from waiting room

This happens when patient devices, staff devices, printers, and servers are all on the same flat network.

The fix is:

  • Separate patient Wi-Fi VLAN
  • Separate staff VLAN
  • Separate printer VLAN
  • Separate tablet/journal VLAN
  • Separate VoIP VLAN
  • Separate card terminal VLAN
  • Separate camera/alarm VLAN
  • Default deny between VLANs
  • Guest/client isolation on patient Wi-Fi
  • Disable printer sharing/mDNS/cloud print where not needed

After this, a patient phone cannot discover or print to your printers.

Problem: Wi-Fi drops in treatment room 3

Thick brick walls will kill Wi-Fi coverage. The fix is not a stronger router; the fix is proper AP placement.

Proposed:

  • Ceiling PoE Wi-Fi AP in each treatment room
  • APs in waiting room/corridors/stairwell
  • Site survey after move, with possible additions if dead spots remain
  • 5 GHz preferred for tablets/staff where supported
  • 802.11k/v/r roaming for staff laptops if supported

I recommend 10–12 APs for the full building. If we install fewer, we may still get dead spots in the old brick rooms.

Problem: Patient journals / sensitive data

You are handling health data, so the network should assume confidentiality is required.

The design uses:

  • VLAN isolation
  • No guest access to clinic systems
  • Restricted tablet access
  • No direct internet exposure of Synology
  • VPN for remote access
  • Encrypted backups
  • MFA/strong admin access
  • Logging and update discipline

I will not say this makes you fully GDPR-compliant — that also depends on Fysiojournal, staff access rights, retention, breach procedures, data processing agreements, etc. But this design is a much safer technical baseline.


3. Proposed network layout
Main assumptions

The following assumes:

  • The vault can be used for rack/NAS/UPS.
  • The vault has power and ventilation.
  • The electrician will run structured cabling.
  • Fibia router is in front desk/ground floor.
  • We place the core network in the basement vault.
  • If distances or cable routes make basement-only patching impractical, we add a small first-floor switch rack/IDF.
High-level topology
Fibia fibre -> Fibia ONT/router in ground floor front desk
                         |
                         | Cat6A or OM4 fibre backbone
                         v
              Basement vault MDF rack
              ----------------------------
              | UniFi Cloud Gateway Max  |
              | Core PoE switch          |
              | Synology NAS             |
              | Patch panels             |
              | UPS                      |
              ----------------------------
                         |
        ---------------------------------------------
        |                     |                     |
   Ground floor           First floor          Basement
   APs, PCs, printers,    APs, tablets,        Alarm cameras
   phones, card terminals printers, phones     (PoE/VLAN)
        |                     |
        -----------------------
                  |
       Optional first-floor IDF switch
                  |
                  | WireGuard VPN
                  v
       Offsite backup NAS at home/another business
Where equipment should go

Basement vault – MDF / main rack
This is the best place for:

  • Synology NAS
  • Core switch
  • Firewall/router
  • Patch panels
  • UPS

However, I need confirmation that the vault has:

  • Clean power for rack/NAS/UPS
  • Ventilation or cooling
  • Acceptable humidity
  • No battery/ventilation issue for UPS
  • Secure access

The steel door is fine for wired gear, but it will block Wi-Fi. That is acceptable because the vault should be wired. If the vault cannot support equipment safely, I would move the rack to a locked technical closet near the front desk and run the backbone from there.

Ground floor front desk
This will contain:

  • Fibia ONT/router
  • A wall box/backbone connection to basement
  • Front desk PCs
  • Front desk printers/card terminal
  • Possibly first AP for waiting area/reception

First floor
If horizontal cable lengths from basement to first-floor far end exceed about 90 m, or if cable routes are difficult, we should add a small first-floor IDF:

  • 19" small rack or wall box
  • 16/24-port switch
  • Fibre uplink to basement

This keeps first-floor Wi-Fi and tablets reliable.


4. What the electrician needs to install

Please send this preliminary cabling plan to the electrician. It is a working baseline, but final quantities depend on room layout and equipment positions.

Cable types
  • Horizontal drops: Cat6A, U/UTP or F/UTP, RJ45 keystone jacks.
  • Backbone: OM4 LC fibre preferred if distance >70 m or between floors.
    If the electrician prefers easier copper and distance is short enough, Cat6A can be used, but fibre is safer for old buildings and long runs.
  • PoE devices: APs, cameras, possibly phones/tablets if supported.
  • Power: Electrician must provide power for rack/NAS/UPS, IDF if used, front desk, tablets if not PoE.
Preliminary data-drop count
CategoryMinimumRecommendedNotes
Fibia entry to basement vault backbone22Cat6A or OM4. One WAN, one spare/management.
Basement vault to first floor backbone02Only if first-floor IDF is needed or distances are long.
Treatment room APs88One ceiling AP per treatment room.
Common-area APs24Waiting room, corridors, stairwell.
Front desk data outlets68PCs, printers, card terminals, AP, spares.
IP phone outlets68Depends on phone placement and whether phones connect through PC ports.
Fixed staff desk/office outlets48Staff desks/laptops/docks.
Treatment room tablet drops08Best practice. If tablets use Wi-Fi only, we can omit these, but wired tablets are more reliable.
Alarm camera drops44PoE Cat6A to camera locations confirmed by alarm company.
Spare drops58Very useful in older buildings.
Approximate Cat6A drops~37~56Depends heavily on tablet/phone/desk layout.

My practical recommendation for a good clinic network:

  • At least 35–45 drops minimum
  • Recommended: 50–60 drops if wall tablets are also wired and you have multiple office/desk locations.

If the electrician must chase walls/ceilings in the old bank building, cost and time can increase significantly.

Electrician requirements

Please ask the electrician to:

  • Use Cat6A for all data drops
  • Terminate both ends and label both ends
  • Provide a cable schedule:
    • e.g. FD-MDF-01, TR-G1-AP, TR-F1-TAB, CAM-01
  • Leave service loops in ceilings and behind plates
  • Test every cable
  • Avoid running data cable too close to mains power where possible
  • Do not rely on powerline adapters or Wi-Fi repeaters

5. IP addressing and VLAN plan

This is the addressing scheme the technician can use. All addresses below are private RFC1918 addresses.

Global assumptions
  • DNS and default gateway for clinic VLANs: .1 in the relevant VLAN.
  • IPv4 only for now. IPv6 can be disabled unless required.
  • Static IPs for infrastructure, printers, NAS, cameras, card terminals.
  • DHCP for staff laptops and guest devices.
  • Longer leases for clinic devices; short leases for guest Wi-Fi.
VLAN / subnet table
VLANNameSubnetGateway / DNSDHCP / static rangeMain devicesAccess rules
10Management10.10.10.0/2410.10.10.1Static .10–.39; spare .40–.99Switches, APs, controller, admin devicesAdmin only; not normal user network
20Staff10.10.20.0/2410.10.20.1Static .10–.49; DHCP .100–.199Front desk PCs, laptopsInternet, printers, Synology, VoIP if needed
30Treatment tablets10.10.30.0/2410.10.30.1Static .100–.199Wall tabletsDNS/NTP and Fysiojournal/cloud allowlist; no general LAN access
40Guest / patient10.10.40.0/2310.10.40.1DHCP .100–.250Patient phones/laptopsInternet only; client isolation; no clinic VLAN access
50Printers10.10.50.0/2410.10.50.1Static .10–.39Network printers, label printer if networkedStaff/tablets may print; no guest access
60VoIP10.10.60.0/2410.10.60.1Static/DHCP .10–.39Telia IP phonesSIP/RTP to Telia; DNS/NTP; no general internet unless required
70Cameras / alarm10.10.70.0/2410.10.70.1Static .20–.59Alarm company cameras/NVROnly to NVR/alarm system; internet only if alarm cloud requires it
80Server / NAS10.10.80.0/2410.10.80.1Static .10 SynologySynology NASStaff and approved VPN access; no tablets/guest
90Card terminals10.10.90.0/2410.10.90.1Static .10–.19Nets terminalsOutbound only to Nets endpoints; no inbound clinic access
Example device IP assignments
DeviceIPVLAN
Core switch management10.10.10.1010
AP 110.10.10.2110
AP 210.10.10.2210
... up to AP 1210.10.10.3210
Synology NAS10.10.80.1080
Printer 110.10.50.1150
Printer 210.10.50.1250
Label printer10.10.50.2150
Card terminal 110.10.90.1190
Card terminal 210.10.90.1290
Telia phone 110.10.60.1160
Telia phone 210.10.60.1260
Alarm camera 110.10.70.2170
Alarm camera 210.10.70.2270
Firewall / ACL approach

Default rule: deny inter-VLAN traffic unless explicitly allowed.

Suggested allow rules:

  • Guest VLAN: DNS, DHCP, internet; deny access to 10.10.0.0/16; client isolation enabled.
  • Treatment tablets: DNS/NTP and only Fysiojournal domains/IPs; deny access to Synology unless you specifically need it.
  • Staff: internet, DNS, printers, Synology, and VoIP as needed.
  • Printers: accept printing from Staff and approved Tablets only; no guest access.
  • Cameras: only to alarm/NVR system; outbound to alarm cloud only if required.
  • Card terminals: outbound to Nets only; deny inbound from Staff, Guest, Tablets, and cameras.
  • VoIP: SIP/RTP to Telia gateway; DNS/NTP; mark traffic for QoS.
  • NAS: Staff VLAN and approved VPN clients only; no direct port forwarding to internet.
  • Management VLAN: only admin machines and approved VPN access.

The technician should create firewall address groups:

  • TABLET_ALLOW
  • PRINTERS
  • SYNOLOGY
  • VOIP_GATEWAY
  • CARD_TERMINAL_DEST
  • CAMERA_NVR
  • ALARM_CLOUD

6. Wi-Fi design
SSIDs
SSIDVLANPurposeSecurityScope / restrictions
Krogh-Staff20Staff laptops/phonesWPA2/WPA3-Enterprise preferred; fallback WPA2-PSK if devices cannot do EnterpriseClinic coverage; roaming for laptops
Krogh-Tablets30Wall tablets for FysiojournalWPA2-Enterprise preferred; fallback WPA2-PSK + MAC filteringTreatment room APs; restricted outbound access
Krogh-Guest40Patient Wi-Fi in waiting roomGuest portal or WPA2-PSK, changed periodicallyWaiting room or clinic-wide with restricted access; client isolation; no printers/Synology/LAN
Optional: Krogh-Mgmt10AP/controller management onlyHidden or not broadcast to usersAdmin only
Important Wi-Fi details
  • Disable or bridge out the Fibia Wi-Fi if possible.
  • Do not let patients use the clinic SSID.
  • Do not let staff laptops use the patient SSID.
  • Treatment tablets should not use patient Wi-Fi.
  • Printer discovery across VLANs may not work via Bonjour/mDNS. Technicians should add printers using IP address, e.g. 10.10.50.11.
  • Use AP groups so patient SSID is only active where you want it.
  • For tablets, if they do not support certificates/Enterprise, I can use a dedicated tablet VLAN with PSK and MAC filtering, but I will note the lower security level. Enterprise/EAP-TLS is strongly recommended if supported.
AP count recommendation

For 2 floors × 180 m² in an old brick building:

  • 8 treatment room APs
  • 2–4 common-area APs
  • Total: 10–12 APs

If you install fewer than 10, you may still get dead zones. If dead zones remain after the move, adding 1–2 extra APs is usually easier than troubleshooting weak coverage caused by thick walls.


7. Phones, card terminals, cameras, printers
Telia IP phones

We will place the 6 Telia phones on the VoIP VLAN and configure QoS.

However, I need Telia documentation before cabling/cutover:

  • Are the phones PoE?
  • Do they connect directly to your LAN/SIP, or do they require a Telia router/PBX?
  • Does Telia provide VLAN settings?
  • Do they need a specific VLAN, DHCP option, or direct outbound SIP/RTP?
  • Do they need a separate internet line?

I cannot guarantee the phones will keep working without these details. In many cases we can make it work, but Telia/Nets sometimes require specific configuration or a Telia-provided device.

Nets card terminals

Card terminals should be isolated.

Proposed:

  • Separate VLAN 90
  • Static IPs
  • Outbound only to Nets endpoints
  • No inbound access from Staff, Guests, Tablets, Printers, or Cameras

I need:

  • Model of terminals
  • Ethernet or Wi-Fi?
  • Whether they require static IP/MAC filtering
  • Whether Nets has network requirements
  • Whether they must be PCI-compliant

If Nets requires a separate router or a specific network design, that may add cost. I can implement network isolation, but I cannot make Nets accept our design without their confirmation.

Alarm cameras

The alarm company says they need “a port and PoE”.

We can provide:

  • Cat6A PoE port
  • VLAN 70 camera network
  • Isolation from clinic network

But I need from the alarm company:

  • Camera model
  • PoE class required
  • Static IP requirements
  • Whether cameras use local NVR or cloud alarm platform
  • Whether they need outbound internet
  • Which IP addresses/domains are allowed

If the alarm company demands full flat network access, I will flag it as a security risk and ask you to confirm in writing whether you accept that risk. For a clinic with patient data, I would not put cameras on the patient or staff network.

Printers and label printer

Recommended:

  • Network printers on VLAN 50
  • Static IPs
  • Disable guest printing, Wi-Fi Direct, Bluetooth printing, and unnecessary cloud print services
  • Add print queues in Staff PCs using IP address
  • Label printer should be networked if possible; if USB only, decide whether to attach it to one PC or use a print server. I would avoid sharing a label printer too broadly.

8. Synology, backup, and remote access
Current Synology

You have around 600 GB of scanned documents and old journals.

Before moving:

  • Check RAID health and SMART status.
  • Run consistency check/scrub if supported.
  • Export DSM configuration.
  • Make a full backup before moving.
  • Label and move carefully.

If your current Synology is old or nearly full, we may need to add RAM or plan a migration later. That is not included in the basic budget unless confirmed.

Backup design: no subscription, second NAS option

If you choose the no-subscription option:

Purchase:

  • One second NAS, ideally Synology-compatible, at home or another business location.
  • Two 4 TB drives mirrored, or 2 × 8 TB if budget allows and you want more room.

Setup:

  • Synology Hyper Backup from clinic NAS to home NAS.
  • Encrypted transfer and encrypted storage.
  • Scheduled nightly, for example 23:00.
  • Retention:
    • 7 daily versions
    • 4 weekly versions
    • 12 monthly versions
    • Versioning enabled
  • Alerts via email.
  • Initial seed locally if internet bandwidth is not enough for first full copy.

What this does:

  • Backup is outside the building.
  • No monthly subscription.

What this does not give you:

  • Managed service
  • Formal SLA
  • Offsite data center
  • Immutable backup in a separate trust domain
  • Professional restore testing unless included as paid work
Better backup if you later accept a monthly fee

For patient data, I would still recommend a managed EU backup service:

  • Encrypted at rest and in transit
  • EU data centre
  • GDPR/data processing agreement
  • Versioning/immutability options
  • Monitoring
  • Restore testing
  • Typical cost: around 50–150 kr/month depending on capacity and vendor.
Remote work
Two physios doing home visits

If they only use Fysiojournal in the cloud:

  • They do not need to connect back to the clinic.
  • They can use mobile data/hotspot.
  • They need:
    • Full disk encryption
    • Screen lock
    • OS updates
    • Browser/app updates
    • Unique user accounts
    • MFA if Fysiojournal supports it
    • No personal email/browser profiles on clinic devices

If they need access to Synology from the car:

  • Create named WireGuard VPN profiles.
  • Restrict access to approved Synology resources.
  • Do not expose SMB/DSM directly to internet.
  • Revoke access if device is lost.
Mette working from home Thursdays

Best setup:

  • Synology Drive Client over HTTPS with 2FA for selected shared folders.
  • Or WireGuard VPN to clinic if you need broader access.

Do not forward ports directly to Synology for file access.

Synology security

We will configure:

  • HTTPS only
  • 2FA for admin and approved users
  • Disable default admin
  • Disable UPnP
  • Disable unnecessary packages/services
  • Firewall rule so only Staff VLAN and approved VPN access NAS
  • No tablets unless you explicitly need tablet-to-NAS access
  • Logs and access control
  • DSM and package updates

9. Equipment list and rough cost

All costs are rough, ex moms/ex VAT.

Existing equipment to reuse

Assuming they are working and will be moved:

  • Synology NAS
  • Front desk PCs
  • Staff laptops
  • Wall tablets
  • 2 printers
  • Label printer
  • Nets card terminals
  • Telia IP phones
  • Fibia ONT/router
  • Alarm cameras supplied/configured by alarm company
Budget-fit network design: aiming near 40,000 kr
ItemQtyPurposeRough ex moms
UniFi Cloud Gateway Max or similar1Router/firewall/UniFi controller/VLAN/WireGuard3,500
24-port PoE+ switch1APs/cameras/phones where PoE needed2,200–3,000
24-port data switch1PCs, printers, phones, tablets, uplinks2,200–3,000
Wi-Fi 6 ceiling APs, e.g. UniFi U610Clinic Wi-Fi, treatment rooms, waiting room8,000–12,000
Backup NAS + 2 drives1Offsite backup target at home/another business5,500–7,500
Rack UPS, ~1500VA1Keep NAS/router alive during short power issues2,000–3,000
9U rack, patch panel, cable management, labels1 setMount and organise equipment1,800–2,800
Fibre media converters/SFP/DAC, patch leads, labelssetBackbone and patching1,000–1,800
Technician labour: survey, pre-config, install, cutover, docs10–12 hInstall/config/migrate/test12,000–15,000
Total budget-fit target~37,000–45,000 kr

If 40,000 kr is a hard cap, I may need to:

  • Use cheaper APs
  • Use 10 APs instead of 12
  • Use 2 × 24-port switches instead of one 48-port PoE switch
  • Use a cheaper router/controller
  • Accept less spare capacity
  • Exclude first-floor IDF switches
  • Keep backup simple

That is possible, but it leaves less margin for growth to 14 staff and for dead-spot fixes.

Recommended more robust design
UpgradeWhyRough additional cost
48-port PoE+ or PoE++ switchMore PoE capacity, more ports, less port juggling+3,000–5,000
12 APs instead of 10Better coverage in brick building+1,500–3,000
Better rack/UPS/cabling accessoriesCleaner installation+500–1,500
First-floor IDF switch if cable distances require itKeeps first floor reliable+3,000–5,000
More thorough testing and documentationLower risk on move day+3,000–6,000
Total recommended~50,000–62,000 kr ex moms, excluding electrician cabling
If adding Fortinet/UTM/firewall subscription

If you want a traditional business UTM firewall with IPS, application control, security subscriptions, support, and formal vendor support:

  • FortiGate hardware plus annual support: roughly +8,000–15,000 kr initial/annual depending on model
  • Enterprise APs/switches may also increase cost
  • Total could easily go to 70,000–100,000+ kr with cabling and support

This is better for some businesses, but it conflicts with your “no monthly subscriptions” preference.


10. What I still need from you before starting

Please answer these points so the electrician and we can move forward.

Budget and scope
  1. Confirm whether electrician cabling is outside the 40,000 kr IT budget.
    If yes, we can target around 40,000 kr for network gear/configuration/backup NAS.
    If no, 40,000 kr is not realistic.
  2. Do you want:
    • Option A: Budget-fit design around 40,000 kr with assumptions above?
    • Option B: Recommended design around 50,000–62,000 kr excluding electrician cabling?
Backup
  1. Choose backup:
    • B1: One-time second NAS at home/another business
      No monthly fee. I will note reduced robustness.
    • B2: Managed cloud backup in EU
      Better for patient data, but monthly fee.
    • B3: Encrypted USB drive rotation
      Cheapest, but manual and higher risk.

If B1, where will the second NAS be placed? Home? Another business? Do you have stable internet there?

Cabling
  1. Confirm you will send the cabling plan to the electrician.
  2. Confirm whether wall tablets will be:
    • Wi-Fi only, powered separately, or
    • Wired/PoE tablets requiring data drop and PoE port.
  3. Do you have floor plans or approximate positions for:
    • AP locations
    • Treatment room tablet positions
    • Printers
    • Card terminals
    • Phones
    • Cameras
    • Front desk PCs
    • Staff desks
Vendor systems
  1. Please get documentation from Telia for IP phones:
    • Phone model
    • PoE requirement
    • Whether they need a Telia router/PBX
    • Required VLAN/IP settings
  2. Please get details from Nets for card terminals:
    • Model
    • Ethernet/Wi-Fi/SIM
    • IP requirements
    • Network restrictions
  3. Please get details from alarm company for cameras:
    • Camera model
    • PoE requirements
    • Static IP requirements
    • Whether they use cloud or local NVR
    • Which outbound internet access is needed
Synology and staff access
  1. What is your current Synology model and how much free disk space does it have?
  2. Which staff need access to Synology?
    • Everyone?
    • Front desk only?
    • Management only?
  3. Which people need home/car VPN access?
    • You only?
    • Some physios?
  4. Do staff laptops need access to local files, or only Fysiojournal and maybe Synology Drive?
Patient Wi-Fi
  1. Should patient Wi-Fi be:
    • Password-based?
    • Guest portal?
    • Only available in waiting room, or clinic-wide?
  2. Do you want guest Wi-Fi terms displayed, e.g. “For personal use; no printing or clinic access”?

11. Things that cannot be done exactly as requested

I want to be clear:

1. Proper offsite backup with absolutely no subscription

This is possible only by owning remote storage yourself, e.g. second NAS at home. But that is not equivalent to a managed offsite backup service. I can implement it, but I cannot recommend it as the most robust solution for patient data unless you accept the risk.

2. 40,000 kr including everything

If 40,000 kr must include all electrician cabling, rack, UPS, equipment, backup, support, and labour, then not realistic for this building and requirements.

3. Guarantee Telia phones and Nets card terminals without vendor info

We can design for them, but if Telia or Nets requires specific equipment/VLAN/router behaviour, we may need extra hardware or a change in design.

4. Putting the rack in the vault without power/ventilation

The vault is a good place physically and security-wise, but only if it can safely host IT equipment. If it lacks ventilation/power, I cannot recommend putting NAS/UPS/router there.

5. Perfectly secure tablet Wi-Fi if tablets are cheap/old/limited

If tablets do not support proper Enterprise security, I can isolate them on a restricted VLAN, but it is not as strong as certificate-based authentication. I will document the limitation.


12. Suggested timeline

Assuming move is 1 February and electrician works week 3:

TimeTask
This weekYou confirm budget assumptions, backup choice, and send vendor details to me/Telia/Nets/alarm company.
Before electrician startsYou approve preliminary cabling plan; I refine if needed and send final drop list to electrician.
Week 3Electrician pulls backbone and data drops; labels and tests.
Before moveI pre-configure router, switch, APs, VLANs, SSIDs, VPN, backup target where possible.
Move day / early FebruaryRack install, patching, NAS move, phone/Nets/camera testing, journal tablet testing, Wi-Fi testing.
First 1–2 weeks after moveAdjust APs, monitor logs, backup verification, fix any dead zones or printer issues.

13. What technician will build

The technician should use the IP/VLAN plan above as the baseline.

Build sequence
  1. Verify cable schedule and cable test results.
  2. Mount rack, UPS, core switch, router/controller, patch panels.
  3. Connect Fibia WAN to router/controller.
  4. Create VLANs and DHCP scopes:
    • 10 Management
    • 20 Staff
    • 30 Tablets
    • 40 Guest
    • 50 Printers
    • 60 VoIP
    • 70 Cameras
    • 80 NAS
    • 90 Card terminals
  5. Assign switch ports:
    • AP ports: PoE + management VLAN
    • Staff/PC ports: VLAN 20 or approved VLAN
    • Tablet ports: VLAN 30
    • Printer ports: VLAN 50
    • Phone ports: VLAN 60
    • Camera ports: VLAN 70 + PoE
    • Card terminal ports: VLAN 90
    • NAS port: VLAN 80
    • Uplinks/backbone: trunk ports
  6. Configure SSIDs and VLAN mapping.
  7. Configure firewall/ACLs as per isolation plan.
  8. Configure QoS for VoIP first, tablets/journal second, clinic general third, guest fourth.
  9. Configure Synology:
    • Static IP VLAN 80
    • 2FA
    • HTTPS
    • shares and permissions
    • Hyper Backup to remote NAS if approved
  10. Configure VPN:
    • WireGuard for backup site if applicable
    • WireGuard client profiles for Mette/needed staff
  11. Test:
    • Guest cannot access printers/NAS
    • Guest cannot access staff network
    • Tablets can access Fysiojournal but not Synology unless approved
    • Staff can print
    • Phones register and calls work
    • Cameras power up and communicate with alarm system
    • Backup job runs
    • VPN access works
    • Wi-Fi coverage in all treatment rooms
  12. Document:
    • Network diagram
    • Final IP plan
    • Final cable schedule
    • Admin credentials list
    • Backup restore guide
    • AP placement map

14. My recommendation

If you want to stay close to 40,000 kr, I would proceed as follows:

  1. Electrician cabling quoted separately.
  2. Use UniFi-style no-license equipment for budget fit, but configure it properly.
  3. Install 10 APs minimum, preferably 12 if budget allows.
  4. Use separate VLANs for guest, tablets, staff, printers, phones, cameras, card terminals, and NAS.
  5. Use one second NAS at home/another business for backup if no subscription.
  6. Get Telia, Nets, and alarm company details before electrician closes walls/ceilings.
  7. Treat move day as a planned cutover, not a plug-and-pray move.

If you can stretch budget to around 55,000–60,000 kr excluding cabling, I would recommend that more comfortably, especially with 12 APs, 48-port PoE switch, better rack/UPS, and first-floor switch if needed.


15. Please reply with approval or choices

To get moving, please reply with:

  1. Cabling scope:
    “Electrician cabling is separate from the 40,000 kr network budget.”
    or
    “All costs must be inside 40,000 kr.”
  2. Network option:
    • Option A: Budget-fit design aiming near 40,000 kr
    • Option B: Recommended design, approximately 50,000–62,000 kr excluding cabling
  3. Backup option:
    • B1: One-time second NAS, no monthly fee
    • B2: Managed cloud backup, monthly fee
    • B3: USB rotation, manual/offline
  4. Tablets:
    • Wi-Fi only
    • Wired/PoE tablets
    • Not sure
  5. Vendor info:
    Can you ask Telia, Nets, and the alarm company for the technical details requested above?
  6. Floor plan / rough layout:
    If possible, send a drawing with rooms, desk positions, tablet positions, AP positions, printers, phones, cameras.

Once I have those, I can give you a final approved network document and a final cost estimate.

Best regards,
[Your name]
IT Consultant

Hy4 Flash

Words per plan: 1,600 to 2,300Access points proposed: 4 to 6
Attempt 110.4 min15,156 tokens

Subject: Netværk for Krogh Fysio – design til godkendelse

Hi Mette,

Thanks for the very clear brief. Jonas pointed me in the right direction 😊

Short version before the detail:

  • Yes, 40.000 kr ex moms is realistic – but only if the electrician’s cable pull is on his own invoice. If his cabling has to come out of the 40.000 kr, we need to cut scope (fewer Wi-Fi spots, no spare access point, cloud backup instead of a second box).
  • One thing you asked for cannot be done exactly as stated: “proper off-site backup with no monthly subscription”. We can avoid a new subscription by using your home internet and a second Synology at home. That is off-site, but self-managed. If you want a hands-off, monitored off-site copy, the realistic price is approx. 100–150 kr/month. Please choose below.
  • The “kid printing from the waiting room” problem is solved by design: patient Wi-Fi and printers will be on separate networks that cannot see each other.

Below is something you can approve, and that a technician can build from.


1. Physical layout / topology

Fibia’s fibre comes in at the ground floor by the front desk. The vault is at the opposite end / basement.

Recommended layout:

Fibia ONT (GF, front desk)
   |
   |  2 x CAT6 pulled by electrician (one active + one spare)
   v
Vault / server cabinet
   - Router/firewall + VPN + Wi-Fi controller
   - 24-port PoE switch (+ small data switch if needed)
   - Synology NAS 10.10.80.10 + local USB backup disk
   - UPS
   - Patch panel
   |
   +--> 5-6 Wi-Fi access points (wired backhaul, not mesh)
   +--> 4 alarm cameras (PoE, own VLAN)
   +--> 6 IP phones (PoE or injectors)
   +--> 8 wall tablets
   +--> 3 front desk PCs, 2 printers, 1 label printer, 2 Nets terminals

Why the vault: steel door is good for physical security. But before we commit, we need to confirm the vault is dry, ventilated and has power. If it is not, we’ll use a small locked cabinet near the vault instead. The fibre-to-vault CAT6 run is then even more important. Thick brick walls are fine for cables, but they make Wi-Fi harder – so all access points must be cabled.


2. Cabling spec for the electrician (week 3)

This is provisional until I see a floor plan, but it is the number he can quote from today. Please give him this list.

AreaRunsNotes
Fibre entry → vault2CAT6, labelled at both ends. One spare.
Front desk93 PC, 2 printers, 1 label printer, 2 Nets terminals, 1 alarm panel
Waiting room1Wi-Fi AP (patient + staff coverage)
Ground floor treatment rooms 1–551× wall tablet in each room
Ground floor treatment corridor1Wi-Fi AP (fixes Room 3 dead spot)
Ground floor phones3Telia IP phones
Cameras4PoE. Need exact positions from alarm company.
First floor treatment rooms 1–331× wall tablet in each room
First floor2Wi-Fi APs (stair/landing + far end)
First floor phones3Telia IP phones
Vault internal2NAS + switch/UPS, plus spare
Total≈ 35 runsPlus a couple of spare data points if budget allows

If the wall tablets do not support PoE, each still needs a normal data point plus local 230 V or a PoE-to-USB splitter. Please confirm.


3. IP addresses and VLANs

We will segment the network. Default rule: nothing can talk to anything unless explicitly allowed.

VLANSubnetDHCPUsed forMain rules
1010.10.10.0/24static .2–.50Switch, APs, UPS, managementAdmin only from VPN / staff
2010.10.20.0/24.100–.20011–14 laptops + 3 front PCsInternet, NAS, printers, Fysiojournal
3010.10.30.0/24.100–.2008 wall tabletsInternet only to Fysiojournal. No NAS, no printers, no guest.
4010.10.40.0/24.100–.200Patient Wi-FiInternet only. Client isolation. No printers, no NAS, no mDNS.
5010.10.50.0/24static .11–.302 printers, label printer, 2 Nets terminalsPrinters reachable from Staff only. Nets terminals only out to Nets.
6010.10.60.0/24static .11–.206 Telia IP phonesQoS priority, Telia access only
7010.10.70.0/24static .11–.144 camerasNo internet. Alarm company NVR / admin only.
8010.10.80.0/24static .10Synology NASStaff + VPN only. Blocked from tablets and guests.

Static addresses are done as DHCP reservations, so no one has to set anything manually on a device.


4. Wi-Fi

Because of the thick brick walls, we will not use wireless mesh between floors. Every access point is cabled back to the switch.

SSIDs:

SSIDVLANSecurity
Krogh-Staff20WPA2-Enterprise (individual accounts) if we run RADIUS on the Synology; otherwise WPA2-PSK with a key changed every 6 months
Krogh-Tablets30Separate key, client isolation
Krogh-Guest40Separate key, client isolation, bandwidth limit, no access to printers/NAS/local devices

Number of APs: 5 installed + 1 spare in the budget. After the move I’ll do a short survey and confirm placement. Room 3 on the old site will not be repeated: the new ground-floor corridor AP is specifically to avoid that.

A captive portal with terms and conditions can be added, but it adds management. Simple rotating guest password is the cheaper and simpler choice unless you want the portal.


5. Security / GDPR
  • Patient journals stay in Fysiojournal (cloud). The Synology is only for legacy scanned documents and old journals, not new journals.
  • That legacy data is personal data. It will be:
    • stored on the NAS in the vault,
    • encrypted at rest where possible,
    • included in the off-site backup,
    • accessible only from Staff VLAN / VPN.
  • MFA on Synology admin and, if Fysiojournal supports it, on Fysiojournal accounts.
  • No default admin accounts, no UPnP, automatic firmware updates.
  • Guest and tablet networks cannot discover or print to printers. This closes the “patient kid printing” issue.
  • I need to know whether you have a data processing agreement with Fysiojournal. If not, that should be sorted in parallel.

6. Backup

Current setup with Lars and the USB disk on Fridays is replaced with an automated 3-2-1 setup:

  1. Primary: Synology in vault. RAID/SHR + snapshots (ransomware protection).
  2. Local copy: USB disk attached to the NAS in the vault, nightly.
  3. Off-site copy: nightly encrypted backup to either:

Option A – no new subscription (recommended by your stated preference):
Second Synology at your home, connected to your home internet.

  • Cost: one-time hardware approx. 2.800 kr.
  • You must confirm your home upload speed (100 Mbit up is enough).
  • The backup is encrypted; keep the encryption key in a password manager, not only in the vault.
  • This is off-site, but self-managed: no one else monitors it.

Option B – hands-off:
Cloud backup (e.g. Wasabi/B2), approx. 600 GB, 100–150 kr/month.

  • Lower hardware cost, but it is a subscription.
  • If you never want a monthly invoice again, choose Option A.

Lars’s manual USB routine is discontinued either way.


7. Remote work
  • You, Thursdays from home: WireGuard VPN into the router. Access only to Staff VLAN and NAS. Not to cameras or guest network.
  • The two physios in the car: They only need Fysiojournal, which is cloud. They do not need VPN. If they also need the Synology, we can give them restricted VPN accounts.
  • Your Fibia 1000/1000 is more than enough; we mainly need to check the upload at your home for Option A.

8. Equipment and rough price (ex moms)

Prices are estimates; final quote will follow after the floor plan and a supplier check.

ItemQtyEst. price
UniFi Dream Machine Pro (router/firewall/VPN/controller)12.900 kr
UniFi 24-port PoE switch + 16-port data switch1+14.400 kr
UniFi U6-LR / U6-Lite AP, 5 installed + 1 spare63.600 kr
Synology DS720+ NAS + 2×4 TB NAS disks13.800 kr
Off-site Synology DS220+ + 2×4 TB disks (Option A)12.800 kr
4 TB USB backup disk1700 kr
UPS 1500 VA11.200 kr
Wall rack, patch panel, labels, small items11.500 kr
PoE injector allowance (if phones/tablets need it)allowance1.000 kr
Hardware subtotal, Option A≈ 21.900 kr

Our work: survey, spec to electrician, installation, configuration, cutover, test, documentation: approx. 18.000 kr (approx. 20 hours).

Estimated total, Option A: ≈ 39.900 kr ex moms
Estimated total, Option B (cloud): ≈ 37.000 kr + 100–150 kr/month

Not included: electrician’s cable pull, Fibia subscription, Nets/Telia charges, alarm company’s cameras/NVR.

If cabling must come out of the 40.000 kr, we should drop the spare AP and use Option B.


9. What I need from you to start
  1. Approve budget and confirm whether electrician cabling is inside or outside the 40.000 kr.
  2. Choose backup: Option A (home NAS, no new subscription) or Option B (cloud, ~150 kr/month).
  3. Send a floor plan of both floors, plus the alarm company’s camera positions.
  4. Confirm the vault has power, ventilation and is dry.
  5. Confirm whether Telia phones require their own router, and whether the phones support PoE.
  6. Confirm wall tablets: PoE or separate power?
  7. Confirm Nets terminals: any special network requirements or fixed IP?
  8. Confirm which printer should be available to whom. I assume front desk only.
  9. Confirm whether there is a DPA with Fysiojournal.
  10. Tell me your home internet upload speed (needed for Option A).
  11. Confirm the 14-person growth: any extra rooms/devices beyond the 8 treatment rooms?

Once I have 1–4, I can give the electrician a final cable list on Monday. The cutover can be done over one weekend around 1 February.

Kind regards,
[Your name]
IT consultant


Straight answers on the tricky bits
  • “No more monthly subscriptions + proper off-site backup” cannot be done with a managed cloud service. It can be done with your home connection and a second NAS, but you own the responsibility for it.
  • Perfect Wi-Fi in an old brick building cannot be guaranteed from a drawing. Five APs is the plan; a survey may say six. The budget has one spare.
  • Server in the vault cannot be confirmed until we check power/ventilation/fire conditions. If the vault is not suitable, we use a locked cabinet nearby and keep the fibre run.
  • 40.000 kr including my time is realistic only if cabling is not included in that number.

Attempt 210.6 min15,494 tokens

Subject: Network design for Krogh Fysio – new clinic (for approval + a few decisions)

Hi Mette,

Thanks for the note, and say hello to Jonas.

Short answer first: yes, 40.000 kr ex moms is realistic for the network equipment and our work, but only if the electrician’s cabling is a separate invoice. His job (about 38 data outlets + 2 fibre runs) will roughly be 12.000–18.000 kr ex moms on top. If the 40.000 kr has to cover his bill as well, we need to cut scope or move to about 55.000 kr.

Two things you asked for are in direct conflict, so I have to be upfront about them:

  1. “No more monthly subscriptions” + “proper backup not in the building” – a cloud backup always has a monthly fee. We can meet both requirements by owning a second Synology at your home or another clinic, with encrypted nightly copy over VPN: no subscription, one-time hardware only. That does depend on your home internet having a decent upload and a public IP. Cloud backup is the simpler fallback at ~150–250 kr/month.
  2. Patients on Wi-Fi + “the kid printed from the waiting room” – we can absolutely stop the printing, but only by putting patients on an internet-only network. If you actually want patients to be able to print, that cannot be done safely with the same printers. We do not recommend that.

Below is the design you can approve, plus the questions I need answered before the electrician starts in week 3.


1. Physical layout / topology
Fibre from Fibia
ONT (ground floor, front desk)
   │  2x LC/LC single-mode fibre (1 active + 1 spare)
   ▼
VAULT / SERVER ROOM (MDF)
  - Router/firewall: UniFi Dream Machine Pro
  - Core switch: 24-port PoE
  - Synology NAS + UPS
   │  2x CAT6A to ground-floor cabinet (1 active + 1 spare)
   │  2x CAT6A to first-floor cabinet (1 active + 1 spare)
   ▼
GROUND FLOOR CABINET        FIRST FLOOR CABINET
  - 16-port PoE switch        - 16-port PoE switch
   │  CAT6A to:                │  CAT6A to:
   - 3 front-desk PCs         - 3 treatment tablets
   - 2 printers + label       - 1 printer
   - 2 Nets terminals         - 2 IP phones
   - 5 wall tablets           - 2 cameras
   - 4 IP phones              - 2 Wi-Fi APs
   - 2 cameras                - 2 spare outlets
   - 2 Wi-Fi APs
   - 2 spare outlets

Important about the vault: the steel door is great for physical security, but it means no usable Wi-Fi in/out of the basement. All Wi-Fi comes from APs on the two floors. The vault also needs normal temperature/humidity (roughly 15–25 °C, dry) and two dedicated power sockets for the equipment + UPS. Please confirm that.


2. Cabling spec for the electrician

Please give him this list. He should label both ends of every cable and deliver a test report (at minimum a wiremap test; preferably a certification test).

FromToCableQtyNote
Fibia ONT, GF front deskVaultLC/LC single-mode fibre21 active, 1 spare
VaultGF cabinet (front/stairs)CAT6A21 active, 1 spare
Vault1F cabinet (top of stairs)CAT6A21 active, 1 spare

Endpoint outlets (CAT6A, keystone + faceplate, labelled at both ends):

Floor / areaDeviceQtyVLANPoE
GF front deskFixed PC320No
GF front deskPrinter130No
GF front deskLabel printer130No
GF front deskNets card terminal230No
GF waiting roomWi-Fi AP150Yes
GF treatment rooms 1–5Wall tablet520Yes (or PoE injector)
GF corridor / roomsIP phone (Telia)440Yes
GF entrance / waitingCamera260Yes
GF rearWi-Fi AP120Yes
GFSpare data outlet2––
1F treatment rooms 6–8Wall tablet320Yes
1F staff areaPrinter130No
1F corridorIP phone (Telia)240Yes
1F corridor / entranceCamera260Yes
1FWi-Fi AP220Yes
1FSpare data outlet2––
VaultNAS, switch, firewall, UPS–10/702x power sockets

Total: approx. 38 CAT6A outlets + 2 fibre runs.

The exact phone/camera/terminal placement is an assumption – see question 4 below.


3. IP addressing and network segmentation

We use 10.10.0.0/16 as the private range. The firewall does DHCP and inter-VLAN routing.

VLANNameSubnetGatewayDHCP rangeUsed for
10Management10.10.10.0/24.1.100–.200Switches, AP management, UPS, NAS management
20Staff10.10.20.0/24.1.100–.200Laptops, 3 fixed PCs, 8 wall tablets
30Devices10.10.30.0/24.1static .10–.50Printers, label printer, Nets terminals
40Voice10.10.40.0/24.1.100–.150Telia IP phones, QoS priority
50Guest10.10.50.0/24.1.100–.200Waiting-room Wi-Fi, isolated
60Cameras/IoT10.10.60.0/24.1static .10–.204 alarm cameras
70Server10.10.70.0/24.1static .10Synology NAS: 10.10.70.10
100VPN10.10.100.0/24.1.2–.50Remote users (Mette + 2 physios if needed)

Key firewall rules:

  • Guest → Internet only. Blocked from 10.10.0.0/16 except gateway/DNS. Client isolation enabled.
  • Staff → Devices, Server, Internet. Staff → Guest blocked.
  • Devices → Internet only (Nets payment gateway). No inbound.
  • Voice → Internet (Telia SIP), QoS priority (DSCP EF).
  • Cameras → alarm company NVR/cloud only; no general internet unless they require it.
  • VPN clients → Server (and Staff only if needed). No full access by default.

This is what stops the patient/kid printing: the printers live on VLAN 30, the guest Wi-Fi is VLAN 50, and there is no route between them.


4. Wi-Fi design

Thick brick walls mean one router in a box will never cover treatment room 3 reliably. We will install 4 managed APs with wired backhaul:

  • 2 on the ground floor: one in the waiting room (guest + staff), one at the rear of the building.
  • 2 on the first floor: one near the stairs, one at the far end.
SSIDSecurityAccess
Krogh-StaffWPA2-Enterprise (individual accounts, no extra licence)VLAN 20, full staff access
Krogh-GuestWPA2-PSK, password changed every 3 monthsVLAN 50, internet only, client isolation

I recommend WAP2-Enterprise for staff rather than a shared password. If you prefer a simple shared password, we can do that, but individual accounts are better for “who did what” with patient journals.

We will do a short Wi-Fi survey after installation. If treatment room 3 is still weak, we add one extra AP: 1.200 kr for the AP + ~800 kr for the cable. I have left this as a contingency line in the budget, not yet purchased.


5. Security, journals and the current USB disk
  • Fysiojournal is cloud-based, so we do not need a local journal server. The “server thing” in the vault is only file storage/backup.
  • The Synology will run RAID 1, encrypted volumes, automatic snapshots and access logging.
  • The current USB-disk routine stops on day one. Taking a disk with old journals home every Friday is a GDPR/data-leak risk. After we have verified a good restore, we will securely wipe that disk.
  • 3 front-desk PCs: we will set them up on VLAN 20 with static leases where needed.
  • 8 wall tablets: wired into VLAN 20. Patients cannot reach them because guest traffic is isolated.

6. Backup and off-site copy

You have ~600 GB today. I suggest:

Primary NAS (in vault): Synology DS423+ with 2 x 4 TB IronWolf in RAID 1 → ~3.6 TB usable, room for growth.
Local protection: daily snapshots + RAID.
Off-site copy: Synology Hyper Backup, encrypted, nightly at 02:00.

Two options for the off-site copy:

OptionWhatCostPros / cons
A – RecommendedSecond Synology DS220+ + 2 x 4 TB at your home or another clinic, site-to-site VPN~4.000 kr + ~1.200 kr UPS, one-timeNo monthly fee. Needs decent upload at the second site and a public IP (or a free relay).
B – FallbackSynology C2 / Backblaze B2 cloud~150–250 kr/monthSimple, no second site needed. Conflicts with “no more subscriptions”.

Please confirm whether you have a second location (your home counts) with reasonably fast upload, and whether it has a public IP. If Fibia or your home provider uses CGNAT, a normal site-to-site VPN cannot be terminated directly; we can then use Synology QuickConnect (free, NAS-only) or a free Tailscale network (no monthly fee, but a third-party relay). I would rather verify this before ordering.


7. Remote work
  • You, from home on Thursdays: WireGuard VPN from the firewall into 10.10.100.0/24, with access to the NAS (10.10.70.10). Your home router must forward UDP 51820 to your laptop, or we install the VPN client on the router if supported.
  • The 2 physios in the car: writing journals in Fysiojournal needs only internet, so no VPN required for that. If they also need files from the Synology, we give them VPN accounts too.
  • Critical check: please confirm with Fibia that you have a public, static IPv4 address. If Fibia gives you CGNAT, we cannot host the VPN at the clinic without a relay; see the backup options above. This is the single biggest technical unknown right now.

8. Equipment list and rough budget (ex moms, DKK)
ItemQtyEst. price
UniFi Dream Machine Pro (router/firewall/VPN)13.500
UniFi Switch 24 PoE (vault)13.200
UniFi Switch 16 PoE (ground + first floor)24.400
UniFi U6-Pro Wi-Fi AP44.800
Synology DS423+ + 2 x 4 TB IronWolf15.000
Off-site Synology DS220+ + 2 x 4 TB (Option A)14.000
UPS 1500 VA (vault) + 1000 VA (home)23.000
Wall cabinets, patch panels, keystones, labels, SFP modules, patch leads1 set3.500
Our time: design, install, config, test, handover~35 h6.000
Total including off-site NAS~38.900 kr
Total if you choose cloud backup instead~34.900 kr + 150–250 kr/month

Not included: the electrician’s cabling (~12–18.000 kr), new laptops/tablets, and any monthly services you already have.


9. What I need from you before we start

Please reply “approved” plus answers to these:

  1. Budget: confirm that 40.000 kr ex moms excludes the electrician’s invoice. If not, we must trim scope.
  2. Off-site backup: do you have a home or other site for a second NAS? If yes, is the upload speed at least ~50 Mbit and do you know if the IP is public?
  3. Fibia: can you confirm with them that you get a public static IPv4? Needed for VPN from home.
  4. Placement: room-by-room, where do the 6 phones, 4 cameras, 2 Nets terminals and 3 printers go? My table above is an assumption.
  5. Telia phones: do they require a special VLAN, DHCP option, or must their own router stay in place? I will disable SIP ALG on our firewall.
  6. Nets terminals: do they just need internet, or do they require a static IP/inbound access?
  7. Alarm company: do the 4 cameras record to their own NVR/cloud, or do they need local storage on our Synology? (Synology includes 2 free camera licences; 2 more are a one-time ~400 kr.)
  8. Vault: temperature/humidity OK, 2 free power sockets, and can we keep the door locked 24/7 with ventilation?
  9. Home visits: do the 2 physios need only Fysiojournal, or also files from the Synology from the car?
  10. Data size: is 600 GB the actual used space on the Synology today, and roughly how much does it grow per year?
  11. Electrician: can he deliver the 38 outlets + 2 fibre runs by week 3? I can send him the table above as a spreadsheet if that helps.

Once I have answers, I can send a final port schedule to the electrician and reserve the hardware so we are ready for 1 February.

Kind regards,

[Your name]
IT consultant


If you approve, I will treat the cabling table, VLAN plan and cost table above as the build spec. If you want any changes, mark them up and I will revise before the electrician starts.

Attempt 39.0 min13,149 tokens

Subject: Network design for Krogh Fysio – approval needed before week 3 cabling

Hi Mette,

Thanks for the thorough description. Below is the design I would send to the electrician and use as the build spec.

Short answers up front:

  • The “kid printing from the waiting room” problem is solvable: patient Wi-Fi goes on its own isolated network with no access to printers, journals, NAS or staff devices.
  • A proper off-site backup with zero monthly cost cannot be fully automatic unless you have a second owned site. The practical no-subscription option is encrypted backup disks rotated off-site. If you want automatic off-site backup, we need a cloud backup subscription or a second site with internet.
  • The 40,000 kr budget is tight. It is realistic only if the electrician’s cabling work is paid separately. If his cabling must come out of the 40,000 kr, this will not fit; cabling alone will likely be 18,000–28,000 kr ex VAT.

1. Physical layout

Proposed layout:

Fibia fibre/ONT
Ground floor, front desk
   |
   | 2 x Cat6A from ONT to vault, or fibre if distance >90 m / electrical isolation wanted
   |
Vault / basement rack
   - UniFi Dream Machine SE
   - Core PoE switch
   - Synology NAS
   - UPS
   - patch panel / SFP uplinks
   |
   | single-mode fibre uplink
   +--> Ground floor cabinet: switch + patch panel --> APs, front PCs, printers, card terminals, phones, tablets
   |
   | single-mode fibre uplink
   +--> First floor cabinet: switch + patch panel --> APs, phones, tablets

The vault is fine for the rack and NAS: steel door, solid door, good physical security. We will not put Wi-Fi in the vault. Thick brick walls mean we use wired access points, not wireless mesh between floors.


2. Cabling list for the electrician

Please tell the electrician to pull approximately 36 Cat6A data outlets, plus backbone links:

LocationCables
8 wall tablets, 5 downstairs + 3 upstairs8
3 front desk fixed PCs3
2 printers + 1 label printer3
2 Nets card terminals2
6 Telia IP phones6
4 cameras4
Wi-Fi access points: 3 ground, 3 first floor6
Spare / future4
Total Cat6A outlets36

Also:

  • 2 x Cat6A from Fibia entry point at the front desk to the vault rack. If the route is longer than 90 m, or if we want better isolation between floors, use 2-strand single-mode fibre instead and confirm with Fibia whether they can move/terminate the ONT.
  • 2 x single-mode fibre runs from the vault to the ground-floor and first-floor cabinets.
  • Power at both floor cabinets and at the vault rack.
  • All outlets labelled room-by-room and patched into a patch panel.

If the tablet models do not have Ethernet, we either add small PoE-to-USB-C adapters at each tablet, or put the tablets on a dedicated Wi-Fi network. I recommend wired where possible.


3. IP addresses and VLANs

We will use a clear 10.42.x.0/24 structure. Gateway is .1 on each subnet.

VLANNameSubnetUsed for
10Management10.42.10.0/24switches, APs, router management
20Staff10.42.20.0/24front PCs, printers, label printer, Nets terminals, staff laptops
25Phones10.42.25.0/24Telia IP phones, QoS enabled
30Clinical10.42.30.0/24wall tablets / journal access
40Guest10.42.40.0/24patient Wi-Fi, internet only
50Cameras10.42.50.0/244 alarm cameras, isolated
60Server10.42.60.0/24Synology NAS
70VPN10.42.70.0/24remote access for you and the two home-visit physios

Example static assignments:

  • UDM firewall: 10.42.10.2
  • Switches: 10.42.10.3 and .4
  • APs: 10.42.10.11–.16
  • NAS: 10.42.60.10
  • Printers: 10.42.20.20–.22
  • Nets terminals: 10.42.20.23–.24
  • Phones: 10.42.25.11–.16
  • Cameras: 10.42.50.11–.14
  • Tablets: 10.42.30.11–.18

DHCP ranges start at .50 on each VLAN.


4. Wi-Fi design

Access points:

  • 3 on the ground floor
  • 3 on the first floor
  • Optional 7th in the basement/stair area if the survey shows a dead spot

SSIDs:

SSIDNetworkSecurity
Krogh-StaffVLAN 20WPA2-Enterprise with individual user accounts
Krogh-ClinicalVLAN 30WPA2-PSK, rotated, only if tablets are not wired
Krogh-GuestVLAN 40WPA2-PSK, client isolation on, password changed quarterly

Guest Wi-Fi rules:

  • Internet only.
  • No access to printers, NAS, patient journals, front desk PCs, cameras or management.
  • Client isolation enabled, so guests cannot see each other.
  • No printing from waiting room.

Fysiojournal is cloud-based, so the tablets only need reliable internet. They do not need access to the server.


5. Security rules

Firewall default is “deny between networks”, then we allow only what is needed:

  • Staff → NAS, printers, card terminals, internet
  • Clinical tablets → internet / Fysiojournal, and optionally only the label printer if needed
  • Guest → internet only
  • Cameras → alarm company/NVR only, no access to clinic LAN
  • VPN → NAS for you, and internet/Fysiojournal for remote physios as needed
  • Management → everything, but only from administrator devices

Also:

  • No default passwords.
  • 2FA on Synology and admin accounts.
  • No port forwarding directly to the NAS.
  • Auto firmware updates, monitored manually.
  • UPS on the rack so a short power cut does not corrupt the NAS.

6. Backup

Current setup with a USB disk that Lars takes home “when he remembers” is not a backup system.

Proposed no-subscription backup:

  • Synology NAS in the vault with RAID and daily snapshots.
  • Daily backup from the NAS to an encrypted external disk.
  • Two backup disks: one in the vault as the latest copy, one always off-site at an agreed location, e.g. Jonas’ office or another approved site.
  • Weekly rotation, plus a documented restore test every quarter.

Important: this is off-site, but not instant and not automatic end-to-end. If you want “set and forget” off-site backup, we need a cloud backup service. For roughly 600 GB–1 TB, expect approximately 100–200 kr/month ex VAT. There is no way to have fully automatic, off-site, third-party backup with no monthly cost unless you own the second site.

Please decide where the off-site disk should live.


7. Remote work

We will set up WireGuard VPN on the UDM. There is no extra licence cost.

  • You, Mette: VPN from home to the NAS only.
  • The two physios: VPN only if they need more than Fysiojournal. If they only write journals in Fysiojournal from the car, they can just use normal mobile internet; no VPN needed.

We need to know whether Fibia can provide a static public IP. If not, we use dynamic DNS. The VPN will be the only inbound service; the NAS will not be exposed directly.


8. Equipment and rough cost, ex VAT
ItemQtyEst. eachEst. total
UniFi Dream Machine SE14,0004,000
UniFi Switch Pro 24 PoE16,5006,500
UniFi Switch Lite 16 PoE12,6002,600
UniFi U6 Pro AP61,1006,600
Synology DS1522+15,5005,500
4 TB NAS disks41,0004,000
5 TB encrypted backup disks29001,800
UPS 1500 VA11,8001,800
Rack, patch panels, SFP modules, labels, small parts12,5002,500
PoE-to-USB-C adapters, if needed81501,200
Hardware subtotal36,500

Our configuration, testing, documentation and cutover: approximately 8,000–12,000 kr ex VAT depending on how much of the cabbing/patching the electrician handles.

So:

  • If cabling is separate: roughly 44,000–48,500 kr ex VAT.
  • If cabling is inside the 40,000 kr: not realistic. Expect roughly 62,000–76,000 kr ex VAT all-in.

We can get closer to 40,000 kr only by removing the spare capacity, which I do not recommend given the old building and thick walls.


9. Decisions I need from you before we start
  1. Is the electrician’s cabling work inside the 40,000 kr budget, or separate?
  2. Where exactly are the 2 Nets terminals, 6 phones and 4 cameras going? Are the cameras indoor/outdoor?
  3. Does the alarm company need just a PoE port and internet, or do they need a local recorder/NVR as well?
  4. Do the wall tablets have Ethernet, or should we budget for PoE-to-USB-C adapters / dedicated tablet SSID?
  5. Where should the off-site backup disk be stored?
  6. Do you want to approve a small monthly cloud backup instead, for automatic off-site backup?
  7. Can Fibia provide a static IP, or should we use dynamic DNS?
  8. Can I get access to measure cable lengths before week 3?
  9. Does Fysiojournal require any IP allowlisting or specific firewall rules?

If you approve the VLAN design, the 36 cable drops, the 6 APs and the backup approach, I can send the electrician the cable schedule on Monday.

Best regards,
[Your name]

Hy4 (full)

Guest
Words per plan: 3,200 to 3,800Access points proposed: 6 to 11
Attempt 166.4 min45,093 tokens

Hi Mette,

English is perfect, thanks — and sorry for the long reply. I’ve written it so you can approve it, and so the electrician/technician can build from it without having to guess.

Short answer on budget: 40,000 kr ex VAT is realistic only as a lean, fixed-scope job that includes the network hardware and my time, but not the electrician’s cable pull, not a replacement Synology, not extra APs after the survey, and not any new monthly subscription. On those assumptions I land at ≈ 39,000 kr ex VAT, and I recommend approving ≈ 41,000 kr with a small 2,000 kr contingency. If “all of it” was meant to include the electrician in an old brick bank, then no, 40,000 kr is not realistic — cabling alone is typically a separate trade quote.

Below is the design I propose. If you reply with the approval line at the end plus answers to the “must confirm” points, I’ll send the one-page cable schedule to the electrician for week 3 and order the hardware.


1. Physical layout and cabling — for the electrician, week 3
Cabinets / rooms
IDLocationContentsPower
Cabinet AGround floor, at the Fibia fibre point by front deskFibia ONT, firewall/controller, main 24-port PoE switch, 48-port patch panel, UPS2 × 230 V: one on UPS, one direct
Cabinet CFirst floor, central corridor/stair area16-port PoE switch, 24-port patch panel, UPS1–2 × 230 V on UPS
Cabinet B / vaultBasement vaultExisting Synology, local USB backup disk, UPS, 2 data outlets2 × 230 V on UPS; must be dry/ventilated

Important vault note: the steel door and thick brick are good for physical security but bad for radio. The Synology goes in the vault on a wired link. The router/firewall, switches and Wi-Fi APs do not go in the vault, and I am not planning Wi-Fi inside the vault. The fibre comes in at the opposite end of the building, so we terminate WAN at Cabinet A and run two cables down to the vault.

Cable specification
  • 39 × Cat6A, solid bare copper, U/FTP or F/UTP, LSZH, no CCA, PoE+ rated.
  • Maximum 90 m permanent link + max 10 m patch. If any run is longer, replace that run with 2-strand fibre plus SFP/media converters — I’ll confirm after the site measure.
  • Terminate on patch panels in the cabinets and on RJ45 keystone jacks at the outlet. No plug-to-plug leads in the walls.
  • Label both ends KF-<floor>-<drop>, e.g. KF-GF-AP2. Give me a simple test/certification report for every link.
  • Shield bonded at the cabinet end if F/UTP is used.
  • All AP/camera/phone positions are PoE from the switches unless noted.
Cable schedule

Cables ending at Cabinet A — 25 runs

QtyLabelToVLAN / usePoE
1KF-GF-ONTFibia ONT wall box → UCG WANWANNo
2KF-A-U1/U2Cabinet A → Cabinet C uplinksTrunk / LAGNo
2KF-A-V1/V2Cabinet A → vaultV1 = Synology, V2 spareNo
4KF-GF-AP1–4Ground ceiling APs: waiting/front desk, TR1–2 corridor, TR3–4 corridor, rear/TR5 + vault-stair corridorAP mgmt + SSIDsYes
2KF-GF-CAM1–2Ground camera positions, exact spots from alarm installer60 Alarm/CameraYes
3KF-GF-FD1–3Front desk: Telia phone + fixed PC behind phone’s PC port20 Staff + 50 VoiceYes, for phone
2KF-GF-NET1–2Nets card terminals, assumed both at front desk70 PaymentNo
2KF-GF-PRN1, KF-GF-LBLPrinter 1 + label printer20 StaffNo
5KF-GF-TR1–5Treatment room tablet positionsPull now, terminate, unpatched in lean versionNo
2KF-GF-SP1–2Ground sparesDisabled/spareNo

If the ONT is already inside Cabinet A, KF-GF-ONT disappears and the total becomes 38 runs.

Cables ending at Cabinet C — 14 local runs, plus the 2 KF-A-U1/U2 uplinks terminate here too

QtyLabelToVLAN / usePoE
3KF-1F-AP1–3First-floor ceiling APsAP mgmt + SSIDsYes
2KF-1F-CAM3–4First-floor camera positions60 Alarm/CameraYes
3KF-1F-PH1–3Telia phones upstairs50 VoiceYes
3KF-1F-TR6–8Treatment room tablet positionsPull now, terminate, unpatched in lean versionNo
1KF-1F-PRN2Second printer, assumed upstairs20 StaffNo
2KF-1F-SP1–2First-floor sparesDisabled/spareNo

Vault: KF-A-V1 → Synology, untagged VLAN 25. KF-A-V2 coiled, labelled, unpatched. No switch or AP in the vault.

Also for the electrician:

  • 8 × local 230 V / USB-C power at the wall-tablet positions, unless you confirm the tablets are PoE.
  • 230 V sockets at Cabinets A, C and vault as above.
  • Camera positions to be marked by the alarm company before drilling. I have assumed 2 cameras per floor.
  • I have assumed 3 Telia phones downstairs / 3 upstairs, both Nets terminals at front desk, printer 1 + label printer downstairs, printer 2 upstairs. If your floor plan differs, we reassign drops; it does not usually change the count.
  • If the Telia phones cannot carry the front-desk PCs on their PC port, add 3 extra PC drops → 42 runs. I’ve left switch spare capacity for this.

2. Addressing and VLANs

Proposed range: 10.77.0.0/16. Gateway is the firewall on 10.77.<vlan>.1. VLAN 1 is disabled. Default policy: deny all inter-VLAN traffic, then allow only the rows below.

VLANNameSubnetTypical useAccess
10MGMT10.77.10.0/24UCG, switches, APs, UPS, controllerIT/admin only; AP native VLAN
20STAFF10.77.20.0/243 front-desk PCs, staff laptops, printersInternet, DNS/NTP, Synology on VLAN 25
25SERVERS10.77.25.0/24Synology 10.77.25.10, local USB backupFrom STAFF + Mette VPN + backup tunnel only
30CLINICAL10.77.30.0/248 wall tablets, SSID KF-ClinicalDHCP/DNS/NTP + HTTPS to Fysiojournal/Internet; deny all 10.77.0.0/16; client isolation
40GUEST10.77.40.0/24Waiting room, SSID KF-GuestInternet only, 50/20 Mbit limit, client isolation, deny all internal incl. printers/NAS/cameras
50VOICE10.77.50.0/246 Telia IP phonesSIP/RTP to Telia only, DHCP/NTP, QoS DSCP EF
60ALARM/CAM10.77.60.0/244 cameras + alarm NVR/panel if neededNTP + alarm vendor VPN/destinations only; no inbound WAN
70PAYMENT10.77.70.0/242 Nets terminalsNets destinations only; no local, no Wi-Fi
80VPN-USERS10.77.80.0/24Mette + IT WireGuard clientsMette → 10.77.25.10 only; IT → MGMT + SERVERS
90VPN-SITE10.77.90.0/30Site-to-site backup tunnel10.77.25.10 ↔ 10.78.10.10 on backup port only

Fixed/reserved addresses:

  • UCG-Ultra: 10.77.10.1
  • Ground switch: 10.77.10.11, first-floor switch: 10.77.10.12
  • APs: DHCP reservations in 10.77.10.20–30
  • Synology: 10.77.25.10
  • Printers: 10.77.20.21–23
  • Cameras: 10.77.60.11–14
  • Nets terminals: 10.77.70.11–12
  • Off-site NAS at your home: example 10.78.10.10 on 10.78.10.0/24 — your home LAN must not overlap 10.77.0.0/16.

Firewall/switch rules for the technician:

  1. UCG WAN ← ONT. LAN port → ground switch port 1 as trunk, native VLAN 10.
  2. Ground switch ports 2–3 → KF-A-U1/U2, LAG/trunk to Cabinet C ports 1–2.
  3. Ground switch port 4 → KF-A-V1, untagged VLAN 25. KF-A-V2 unpatched/shutdown.
  4. AP ports: native VLAN 10, tagged 20/30/40. UniFi AP profile.
  5. KF-GF-FD1–3: untagged VLAN 20 + tagged VLAN 50 via LLDP/voice VLAN, PoE on.
  6. Camera ports: untagged 60, PoE on. Payment/printer ports: untagged 70/20, PoE off.
  7. Treatment-room drops and spares: unpatched/shutdown in the 40k version.
  8. Allow MGMT → Synology RADIUS UDP 1812/1813, syslog UDP 514, NTP.
  9. Allow STAFF → SERVERS: TCP 445, 5001, 22 for admin only.
  10. Allow CLINICAL/GUEST → DHCP/DNS/NTP + TCP 443; explicitly drop anything to 10.0.0.0/8, 172.16.0.0/12, 192.168.0.0/16.
  11. Allow VOICE → Telia SIP/RTP only; SIP ALG off unless Telia requires it.
  12. Allow ALARM → NTP + vendor VPN/destinations; no WAN inbound.
  13. Allow PAYMENT → Nets destinations only.
  14. Site-to-site VPN: only 10.77.25.10 ↔ 10.78.10.10 on the Hyper Backup port.
  15. Disable UPnP, WAN admin, VLAN 1, unused ports. Local UniFi admin + TOTP 2FA, no cloud-only login.

3. Equipment and rough cost, ex VAT / ex moms

Prices are rough, early-2025 distributor prices, ex VAT. I’ll only order after your written approval.

QtyItemEst. ex VAT
1UniFi Cloud Gateway Ultra — router/firewall, local UniFi Network controller, WireGuard VPN, no licence1,400 kr
1UniFi USW-24-PoE — Cabinet A, 24×1G, 16× PoE+, ~250 W5,200 kr
1UniFi USW-Lite-16-PoE — Cabinet C, 16×1G, 8× PoE+, ~75 W2,400 kr
7UniFi U6-Lite APs — 4 ground + 3 first floor, all wired backhaul6,000 kr
3600–800 VA UPS — Cabinet A, Cabinet C, vault2,800 kr
1 lot9U + 6U cabinets, 48-port + 24-port patch panels, vault keystones, patch leads, labels, faceplates, cable management3,000 kr
1 lotPrimary Synology refresh: 2 × 4 TB NAS disks in SHR/RAID1 + 2 TB USB local backup disk + cables3,000 kr
1 lotOff-site backup kit: 1-bay Synology + 4 TB disk + small WireGuard router for your home + PSU/UPS4,000 kr
—My time: site survey, electrician brief, staging, config, cutover, test, documentation, 2 h handover — approx. 15 h × 750 kr11,250 kr
Subtotal≈ 39,050 kr
Recommended contingency — one extra AP / PoE injector / SFP / minorSynology replacement contribution2,000 kr
Recommended approval≈ 41,000 kr ex VAT

Not included / assumptions:

  • The electrician’s cable pull, conduits, sockets, brickwork and his termination labour are separate. In an old brick building this is often 15–25,000 kr by itself. If you intended 40,000 kr to include him, we need to re-scope.
  • Existing 8 tablets, 6 Telia phones, 3 fixed PCs, laptops, 2 printers + label printer, 2 Nets terminals, 4 cameras, Fibia ONT are supplied by you/vendors. We provide ports, PoE, VLANs and config.
  • The existing Synology is assumed to have 2+ bays, healthy disks, current DSM and to support RADIUS/Hyper Backup/Btrfs. If it must be replaced, add ≈ 4,000 kr for a 2-bay DS224+ class box.
  • No new monthly subscriptions are added. Existing Fibia/Telia/Fysiojournal/alarm subscriptions remain.

If you want the more robust version — UDM-Pro rack firewall, 48-port PoE switch, U6-Pro APs, wired/PoE outlets to all 8 treatment rooms, 8 APs, larger UPS — budget ≈ 48–52,000 kr ex VAT plus electrician. I’d recommend it if budget allows, but it is not the 40,000 kr design.

Known upgrade triggers:

  • Cameras are 802.3at/PTZ/heated, or tablets need PoE → upgrade first-floor switch to USW-24-PoE: +2,800 kr, plus PoE tablet adapters if needed ≈ 350 kr × 8.
  • Survey shows treatment rooms need an 8th AP: +900 kr.
  • Any uplink >90 m → fibre + SFPs: ≈ +1,200 kr.
  • UDM-Pro instead of UCG-Ultra: +1,300 kr.

4. Wi-Fi
  • 7 wired APs, no mesh/repeaters. Every AP has a Cat6A backhaul. Thick brick means we use more APs at lower power, not one loud box.
  • WiFi 6, 2.4 GHz on 1/6/11 @ 20 MHz, 5 GHz @ 40 MHz, 802.11r/k/v for roaming. I do not rely on 6 GHz through brick.
  • Controller runs locally on the UCG-Ultra, no licence.
SSIDVLANAuthWho / whatPolicy
KF-Staff20WPA2-Enterprise via free Synology RADIUS; fallback to strong PSK if the Synology model can’t run RADIUSStaff laptops, 14 accountsInternet + Synology + printers
KF-Clinical30WPA2-PSK, 20+ chars, stored in your password manager8 wall tablets onlyInternet/Fysiojournal only, client isolation, no NAS/printers/guest/cameras
KF-Guest40Simple WPA2 password on a sign at reception, rotated monthlyPatients/waiting roomInternet only, 50/20 Mbit, client isolation, cannot print, cannot see NAS, cameras, phones or payment terminals
———VaultNo Wi-Fi. Steel door blocks it; wired only.

The printing incident is fixed two ways: guest traffic is firewall-denied to the entire internal range, and I will disable Wi-Fi Direct / cloud printing / Bluetooth on the printers and give them static addresses in VLAN 20. Even if a visitor knows a printer IP, the firewall drops it.

I will do a short site survey in week 2 before the electrician finalises AP positions. Treatment room 3 gets its own nearby AP zone. If the brick is worse than expected and we need another AP, that is the 900 kr item above, not a redesign.


5. Security and patient journals

Current journals live in Fysiojournal in the cloud, but the 600 GB of scans/old journals on the Synology is still patient data. I am not your data protection officer, but I’ll give you a short technical note for your GDPR records. Please have the clinic’s responsible person approve the encrypted off-site copy described below.

Security baseline:

  • Default-deny segmentation as in section 2.
  • Individual accounts, no shared “Lars” login; remove leavers promptly.
  • 2FA on Fysiojournal, Synology DSM and UniFi admin (free TOTP apps, no paid service).
  • Synology archive share encrypted at rest or at minimum all backups encrypted; we need to agree who enters the encryption key after a reboot.
  • Synology audit log + firewall/switch syslog to the Synology, 90 days retention; failure alerts to a clinic mailbox you give me.
  • Laptops: BitLocker/FileVault + auto-lock. I can enable it, but ongoing device management is not included.
  • Printers: Wi-Fi Direct off, cloud print off, static IPs, staff VLAN only. Optional PIN/secure print if the models support it.
  • Nets terminals: isolated VLAN 70, Wi-Fi off, only Nets destinations. This helps PCI scope; I am not certifying PCI DSS.
  • Telia phones: dedicated voice VLAN with QoS. I cannot guarantee they keep working until Telia confirms whether they need their own CPE, DHCP options, a tagged VLAN, SIP proxy/ALG settings or static IPs. We will do a test call with Telia before go-live.
  • Alarm cameras: 4 PoE ports on VLAN 60, no inbound Internet access. The alarm company’s remote access must be via their VPN/specified destinations. I need their camera PoE class and whether their recorder/panel also needs a port.
  • No QuickConnect, no exposed DSM ports 5000/5001, no port forwards to the Synology.

6. Backup — and the “no more subscriptions” conflict

Design: 3 copies, 2 media, 1 off-site, no subscription.

  1. Primary: existing Synology in the vault, refreshed to 2 × 4 TB in SHR/RAID1, Btrfs snapshots daily, 30 kept. 10.77.25.10.
  2. Local: 2 TB USB disk permanently attached to the Synology, automated Hyper Backup daily 22:00, versioned. Lars stops taking the Friday disk home; if he still wants to, that becomes a 4th manual copy, not the backup we rely on.
  3. Off-site: clinic-owned 1-bay Synology + 4 TB disk placed at your home, reached over a WireGuard site-to-site tunnel. Nightly 01:00 encrypted Hyper Backup, AES-256, key held by the clinic in your password manager + sealed envelope. Retention: 30 daily / 12 monthly / 3 yearly. We test-restore one file before sign-off. Alerts go to the clinic mailbox.

Plain answer: a monitored, automatic, off-site backup with zero recurring cost and zero responsibility on your side cannot be done. The no-subscription version is the home NAS above. It needs:

  • your home broadband, power and a little space;
  • a public endpoint on the Fibia line — see below;
  • your approval to keep an encrypted copy of patient data at a private home;
  • acceptance that if the home NAS is offline, stolen, moved or its disk fails, backup stops. We get email alerts, but there is no vendor SLA.

If that is not acceptable, the alternative is a paid EU datacentre/cloud backup — roughly 50–150 kr/month for this volume — which conflicts with “no more monthly subscriptions”. I need a clear decision on this.

Fibia/CGNAT check: I have assumed the 1000/1000 line gives a public IPv4 (or usable IPv6) and is not behind CGNAT. If Fibia hands off behind CGNAT, Mette’s VPN and the home-backup tunnel cannot be reached inbound. We would then need a public/static IP from Fibia — often a small paid add-on — or a relay subscription. Please confirm the handoff type with Fibia before I order.


7. Remote work
  • Two physios doing home visits: they do not get a clinic VPN. Fysiojournal is cloud, so they use their own 4G/5G/home Wi-Fi directly to Fysiojournal with 2FA, device encryption and screen lock. Routing them through the clinic adds no security and breaks when the clinic Internet is down. If Fysiojournal requires a clinic IP allowlist, tell me now — that changes this.
  • Mette on Thursdays: WireGuard remote-access VPN on the UCG-Ultra, individual certificate + 2FA, split tunnel so only traffic to 10.77.25.10 goes to the clinic. Then \\10.77.25.10\Arkiv / DSM over HTTPS. No QuickConnect and no public DSM link. If you wanted “just click a browser link from home” without VPN, I won’t do that with old patient journals.
  • Your home LAN must not overlap 10.77.0.0/16. A normal 192.168.1.0/24 is fine; please confirm your home router subnet and whether it supports WireGuard. If not, the small router in the off-site kit handles it.

8. Things that cannot be done exactly as asked
  1. “Use the vault for the server thing” — Yes for the Synology. No for the router/Wi-Fi/controller. Steel door + brick = no radio, and the fibre is at the opposite end. The vault is wired-only.
  2. “Proper backup not in the building, but no more monthly subscriptions” — Only via one-time hardware at a second site you control, with the home-NAS caveats above. Otherwise it is a subscription.
  3. “40,000 kr for all of it including your time” — Realistic only as the lean scope above, excluding the electrician, a replacement Synology, extra APs, static-IP add-ons and PoE tablet adapters. If the electrician is included: no.
  4. “I need the Synology from home” — Yes, but via VPN + 2FA, not by exposing Synology to the Internet.
  5. “Home-visit physios write journals from the car” — Yes, but directly to Fysiojournal, not through the clinic VPN.
  6. “Phones/cameras/Nets need to keep working” — I’ll design for it, but I need Telia, Nets and the alarm installer’s exact requirements before I can guarantee it.
  7. “Patient’s kid printed from the waiting room” — This will not be possible in the new design.

9. What I need you to decide or clarify before I start

Must answer before week 3:

  1. Budget: approve the lean design at ≈ 41,000 kr ex VAT incl. 2,000 kr contingency, electrician separate, or tell me 40,000 kr is a hard cap and I hold the contingency. Confirm whether the electrician’s invoice is separate.
  2. Floor plan: room numbers, and confirm 3 phones down / 3 up, both Nets terminals at front desk, printer 2 upstairs, label printer network or USB. Which room is “treatment room 3” in the new building?
  3. Synology: model, number of bays, DSM version, disk health/current RAID, admin/2FA owner. Approve replacement if it’s single-bay/end-of-life (+4,000 kr).
  4. Tablets: Wi-Fi only or PoE/wired? Are the 8 tablets supplied, kiosk-locked, and do they cache journals locally? Need Fysiojournal FQDN/IP list, MFA status, and whether an IP allowlist exists.
  5. Telia: contact, phone models, PoE class, PC-port/LLDP support, DHCP options/VLAN/SIP proxy, whether their CPE stays. Book a test call.
  6. Nets: terminal models, IP/Ethernet vs 4G, required destinations/ports, Wi-Fi disabled, 2 locations.
  7. Alarm company: 4 camera positions, PoE class/wattage, NVR/panel port, static IPs, remote-access method, any need for inbound Internet, and whether anything in the vault/basement needs wired alarm/mobile path.
  8. Fibia: DHCP vs static, WAN VLAN tag, public IPv4 vs CGNAT, IPv6, ONT location, any supplied router to bridge, cost of static IP if needed.
  9. Off-site backup: approve clinic-owned encrypted NAS at your home; confirm home broadband, power, space, home LAN subnet, router/WireGuard support, who is responsible if it fails, and GDPR/data-responsible approval. Choose home NAS or paid cloud backup.
  10. Alerts: a clinic mailbox/SMTP for backup, UPS and firewall alerts.
  11. Guest Wi-Fi: password-on-sign vs captive portal, opening hours, who rotates the password. My default: simple password sign, no portal user database.
  12. Vault: confirm power, ventilation, no damp, keys/cabinet access, and that no Wi-Fi/mobile coverage is expected inside.
  13. Cutover: move date 1 February, electrician week 3. I need a 2–3 hour evening test window before go-live and a named contact who can approve changes.
  14. Old setup: list anything on the current ISP box that must survive — port forwards, static routes, alarm/Telia/Fysiojournal exceptions — so we don’t “clean up” something critical.

10. Timeline and approval
  • Week 2: site survey, measure longest runs, confirm Fibia/Telia/Nets/alarm details.
  • Week 3: I send the electrician the final one-page cable schedule; he pulls 39 Cat6A runs and installs cabinet power.
  • Week 4: terminate, label, mount cabinets/APs, configure UCG/VLANs/Wi-Fi/VPN/backup, update Synology.
  • Before 1 Feb: evening cutover + test checklist: guest cannot print, tablet cannot reach NAS, TR3 Wi-Fi, Telia call, Nets transaction, camera feed, Mette VPN, off-site backup + test restore.
  • 1 Feb: go-live. One week later: short review.

If you reply with:

Approved: lean design, max 41,000 kr ex VAT incl. 2,000 kr contingency, electrician separate. Off-site encrypted NAS at my home approved. Guest password sign. UCG-Ultra, 7 APs. Answers to the must-confirm list attached.

…I’ll brief the electrician and order hardware. If any answer changes the assumptions, I’ll re-quote before spending anything.

Thanks, and congratulations on the new place — this is very fixable, and the main thing is that we pull enough cable now while the walls are open.

Best regards,
[Your name]
IT consultant, Krogh Fysio project

Attempt 255.4 min37,529 tokens

Subject: Re: netværk?? – Krogh Fysio network design, draft v1.0 for approval

Hej Mette,

English is perfect, no need to apologise — and thanks to Jonas for the introduction. I have turned the “netværk??” into a buildable design below. Sections 2–5 plus the equipment list are what a technician can build from; section 8 is what I need back from you before I issue a fixed quote and the final cable list for the electrician in week 3.

All prices are DKK, ex moms / ex VAT, rounded ±10 %.


1. Short answers first

Is 40.000 kr ex moms, including my time, realistic for all of this?
No — not for the full scope. A realistic turnkey budget is ca. 64.000–72.000 kr ex moms, target ca. 68.000 kr, excluding the electrician’s cable/230 V work. The 40.000 kr roughly covers the network hardware plus only a very small installation. I can phase it to ~40.000 kr, but then backup, remote Synology access, restore test and some survey work are postponed — see section 7.

Things that cannot be done exactly as asked / need saying up front:

  1. The vault is not an offsite backup. It is still in the building. I propose the vault for the primary Synology; the offsite copy is a second encrypted NAS at your home.
  2. “No more monthly subscriptions” is doable, but not “free cloud backup”. Zero new subscriptions means: local controller, WireGuard VPN, Synology Hyper Backup to a one-time-purchased NAS at your home, free DDNS/Let’s Encrypt, no Meraki/Aruba Central/cloud backup/SMS portal/QuickConnect relay. If you want offsite backup with no box at home and no monthly fee, that cannot be done reliably/GDPR-compliantly.
  3. The steel vault cannot be the Wi-Fi/server room as-is. The steel door and brick block Wi-Fi/mobile, and a sealed vault overheats. The Fibia handover, router/firewall and main switch stay at the front desk where the fibre arrives. The vault gets wired uplinks, power, ventilation, UPS and the NAS only — no AP. If there is no ventilation/temperature control, we put the NAS in the ground-floor rack instead.
  4. One central AP or a mesh/repeater will not cover thick brick. We need wired ceiling APs per zone and a survey. I have budgeted 6 APs; a 7th may be needed after the survey.
  5. I will not expose the Synology via QuickConnect or port 5000/5001 for your Thursdays. Patient data means WireGuard VPN only — one extra click on your laptop, but no open admin port.
  6. Full 1000/1000 with IPS, DPI, VPN and inter-VLAN firewall enabled is not guaranteed on a 1 Gbit gateway. Expect ~600–900 Mbit depending on features. If line rate with everything on is mandatory, we upgrade the gateway/10G at extra cost — please confirm.
  7. The waiting-room printing can and will be stopped, but that also means wall tablets and guests cannot print. Guest/tablet VLANs get explicit deny to printers and no mDNS/AirPrint reflection.
  8. Telia, Nets and the alarm company need to give us their config. I can keep the 6 phones working, but not by guessing VLAN/DHCP/SIP settings. Same for Nets allowlists and camera PoE/NVR.

I have treated “the server thing” as the Synology with the 600 GB of scans/old journals, not the Fibia router. If you meant everything in the vault, see point 3.


2. Physical layout and cabling for the electrician (week 3)
Cabinets
IDLocationContents
MDFGround floor, by Fibia ONT / front deskFibia ONT, firewall/router, 24-port PoE switch, patch panel, UPS, local controller. 6–9U wall cabinet, 2 × 230 V, ventilation.
IDF-1First floor, central corridor/staff area16-port PoE switch, patch panel, UPS, 2 uplinks from MDF. 6U wall cabinet, 230 V.
IDF-VBasement vault8-port managed switch, primary Synology, UPS, temp/humidity sensor, 2 uplinks from MDF. 6U cabinet, 2 × 230 V, ventilation/dehumidifier and smoke/heat detector to be confirmed.

The fibre stays at the MDF. We run two uplinks from MDF to IDF-1 and two uplinks from MDF to IDF-V (LAG, or one active + one spare). Because it is an old bank with thick brick and a steel vault, I recommend fibre for those 4 uplinks; if the electrician prefers all copper, 36 × Cat6A is acceptable only if every measured run is <90 m horizontal.

Data drops to pull

Solid copper Cat6A, LSZH/Euroclass per fire rules, no CCA, terminated on patch panels at the cabinet and RJ45 keystones at the device, labelled both ends KF-01 … KF-36, 30 cm service loop, certified test report + as-built drawing (not just a cable tester beep). Keep clear of 230 V, cross at 90°.

DropQtyFrom → ToNote
KF-011Fibia ONT → MDFWAN handover
KF-02–043MDF → ground AP1–AP3Ceiling, PoE
KF-05–073MDF → front desk PC1–PC3Staff VLAN
KF-08–103MDF → printer 1, printer 2, label printerStaff VLAN; confirm label is network or USB
KF-11–122MDF → Nets terminal 1–2Payment VLAN, wired
KF-13–153MDF → Telia phones G1–G3Voice VLAN, PoE
KF-16–172MDF → cameras G1–G2Camera VLAN, PoE
KF-18–192MDF → ground sparesFront desk / future
KF-20–212MDF ↔ IDF-1 uplinks A/BOr 1 × duplex fibre
KF-22–232MDF ↔ IDF-V uplinks A/BOr 1 × duplex fibre, recommended
KF-24–263IDF-1 → first-floor AP4–AP6Ceiling, PoE
KF-27–293IDF-1 → Telia phones F1–F3Voice VLAN, PoE
KF-30–312IDF-1 → upstairs printer + spare/2nd printerStaff VLAN
KF-32–332IDF-1 → cameras F1–F2Camera VLAN, PoE
KF-34–352IDF-1 → first-floor spares—
KF-361IDF-V → vault spare / sensor—

Total: 36 data drops.
If we use fibre uplinks: 32 × Cat6A + 2 × duplex OM3/OS2 LC/LC + SFP modules; same labels, KF-20–23 become fibre. If the alarm company puts all 4 cameras on one floor, move KF-32/33 or KF-16/17 — total stays 36. If the label printer is USB-only, KF-10 becomes a spare — total stays 36. If they add an NVR in the camera VLAN, we convert one spare to that drop.

Power-only (not data)
  • P-01 … P-08: 8 × 230 V + USB-C (or PoE-to-USB-C, see decision 6) at the wall tablets in the 8 treatment rooms. Tablets are Wi-Fi only on the Journal SSID; they do not get a data drop.
  • 230 V at each printer, fixed PC, card terminal and any non-PoE phone/tablet charger.
  • 2 × 230 V + UPS in MDF, IDF-1 and IDF-V; UPS in vault must support graceful NAS shutdown.
  • Vault: ventilation/heat removal, humidity check, smoke/heat detector, key/access arrangement.

Assumption: the electrician’s cabling and 230 V work is in the moving/renovation budget, not in my 40.000/68.000 kr quote. If you intended it inside my quote, the answer is definitely no.


3. Addressing, VLANs and firewall policy

I propose 10.47.x.0/24 to avoid clashes with common 192.168.1.x home routers, Telia boxes and guest devices. Please confirm your home router is not already using 10.47.0.0/16.

VLANNameSubnet / gatewayDHCPDevicesAccess
10Management10.47.10.0/24, GW .1.50–.99; static .2–.49UDM Pro .1, switches .2–.4, APs .11–.16, UPS .20–.22IT/admin VPN only
20Staff / Clinical10.47.20.0/24, GW .1.50–.19911 laptops + 3 front desk PCs; printers .20–.23Internet, DNS/NTP, printers, NAS, Fysiojournal
25Servers / NAS10.47.25.0/24, GW .1nonePrimary Synology 10.47.25.10From Staff + VPN only; NAS → offsite backup
30Voice10.47.30.0/24, GW .1.50–.99 + Telia options6 Telia IP phonesTelia SIP/RTP, DHCP/DNS/NTP; DSCP EF QoS
40Journal tablets10.47.40.0/24, GW .1.50–.898 wall tabletsDNS/NTP + Fysiojournal HTTPS + MDM push only; client isolation
50Guest / patients10.47.50.0/24, GW .1.50–.199Waiting roomInternet only, client isolation, ~50/50 Mbit cap, DNS filter
60Payment10.47.60.0/24, GW .1reserved .10–.112 Nets terminalsNets allowlist + DNS/NTP only, wired, no Wi-Fi
70Cameras10.47.70.0/24, GW .1reserved .10–.134 cameras (+ NVR if supplied)Alarm-company NVR/cloud allowlist + DNS/NTP; admin via VPN/Mgmt
999Native / blackholeno IP, shutdown—trunk nativePrevents VLAN hopping
—WireGuard VPN10.47.200.0/24.10 Mette, .11–.20 physiosRemote laptopsSplit tunnel to VLAN 20/25/10 only
—Home/offsite LAN10.47.210.0/24.1 home VPN router, .10 offsite NASMette homeRouted over site-to-site WireGuard

Firewall: default deny all inter-VLAN. Explicit allows only:

  • Staff → printers (VLAN 20), NAS 10.47.25.10 (SMB/HTTPS), Internet, Fysiojournal.
  • Tablets → DNS/NTP/Fysiojournal only; deny 10.47.0.0/16.
  • Guest → DNS/HTTP/HTTPS only; explicit deny to 10.47.0.0/16, printers, NAS, phones, cameras, payment; no mDNS/Bonjour reflection; AP client isolation. This is why the waiting-room printing cannot recur.
  • Voice → Telia SIP/RTP only; Payment → Nets only; Cameras → alarm NVR/cloud only.
  • NAS → 10.47.210.10 over WireGuard/Hyper Backup only; no inbound Internet, no QuickConnect, no exposed DSM.
  • Management/VPN-admin → network devices + NAS; no staff/guest access to switch/AP logins.
  • UPnP, WPS, SMBv1 disabled; local logging on the gateway (30 days); IPS/DPI on with the throughput caveat above.

4. Wi-Fi
  • 6 wired UniFi U6-Pro/LR APs, all with Cat6A/PoE backhaul. No mesh, no repeaters — brick walls make them unreliable.
  • Placement:
    • Ground: AP1 waiting/front desk, AP2 corridor by treatment rooms 1–3 (this is the “room 3” fix), AP3 far end rooms 4–5 / vault stairs.
    • First: AP4 rooms 6–7, AP5 room 8 / far end, AP6 staff/office/meeting.
  • 2.4 GHz channels 1/6/11 at low/medium power; 5 GHz planned after survey; band steering on staff. Final channels/power after a 2-hour on-site RF survey before week 3.
  • Target in every treatment room: ≥ −67 dBm and ≥25 Mbit. If any room fails, add AP7 in that room (+1 drop, ~1.200 kr).
  • No AP in the vault. Steel door = no useful Wi-Fi; NAS/switch are wired only.
SSIDVLANAuthNotes
KF-Staff20WPA2/WPA3-Personal, strong PSK14 staff by summer; optional WPA2-Enterprise with local RADIUS, no licence, +4 h
KF-Journal40WPA2/WPA3-Personal8 tablets, client isolation, Internet/Fysiojournal only
KF-Guest50WPA2/WPA3-PersonalPatient Wi-Fi, client isolation, bandwidth cap, PSK at reception, rotate quarterly; simple built-in hotspot page if wanted, no subscription

5. Security, backup and remote work

Patient journals / GDPR. Yes, it matters. Baseline: MFA on Fysiojournal, Synology and network admin; BitLocker/FileVault + screen lock on laptops; encryption at rest on NAS; encrypted backups; local audit logs; no journal data on guest Wi-Fi or unencrypted USB; databehandleraftale with Fysiojournal, Telia, Nets, alarm company and with me before I touch journal data. Retention/version policy to be confirmed by you/your accountant/DPA — I will not auto-delete old journals.

Primary NAS (vault). Reuse the existing Synology only if it has 2+ bays, current DSM, healthy disks and supports Hyper Backup; otherwise replace. Refresh to 2 × 4 TB NAS disks in RAID1/SHR (600 GB fits easily), shares for Scans, OldJournals, Backup, snapshots on, recycle bin on, UPS graceful shutdown, temp/humidity alarm. RAID is availability, not backup.

Offsite backup (not in the building). New 2-bay Synology + 2 × 4 TB RAID1 at your home, on 10.47.210.10. Nightly Hyper Backup over a WireGuard site-to-site tunnel, AES-encrypted with the key held by the clinic, versioned (e.g. 30 daily / 12 weekly / 12 monthly), integrity check monthly, restore test quarterly. Initial 600 GB is seeded at the clinic before moving the box, because home upload may be slower than 1000/1000. Your home NAS stays powered/on internet; the data is unreadable to the household because it is encrypted. Zero monthly fees. Lars’ Friday USB disk is retired as the primary backup; optional 3rd copy = 2 encrypted USB disks alternated weekly with a signed checklist, not relied upon. I do the first restore test at handover.

Remote work.

  • Mette, Thursdays: free WireGuard client on your laptop → 10.47.25.10 only (plus admin if needed). No browser shortcut to an exposed NAS.
  • Two physios / car: Fysiojournal is cloud, so they use HTTPS + MFA over mobile/car Wi-Fi; no VPN needed for journals. If they need old scans, same WireGuard client, restricted to VLAN 25.
  • No new subscriptions: controller, VPN, backup, DDNS, certificates and optional RADIUS all run locally/free. Only one-off hardware + my time. A managed monitoring/SLA would be a separate, optional subscription and is not proposed.

6. Equipment and rough costs
QtyItemRough ex momsNote
1UniFi Dream Machine Pro3.000 krRouter/firewall + local UniFi Network controller + WireGuard + IPS/DPI, no licence
1UniFi USW-Pro-24-PoE5.500 krMDF; 24 × 1G PoE+, 400 W — covers 6 AP + 4 cameras + 6 phones + 2 terminals
1UniFi USW-16-PoE2.700 krIDF-1; 150 W for 3 AP + 3 phones + 2 cameras
1UniFi USW-8900 krIDF-V; NAS + uplinks, VLAN-aware, no PoE needed
6UniFi U6-Pro / U6-LR APs7.200 krWired backhaul; final model/count after survey
24 TB NAS drives, primary1.800 krRAID1 refresh in vault; deduct if existing disks are healthy/current
1Offsite DS223j + 2 × 4 TB4.000 krEncrypted backup target at your home
1Home WireGuard router700 kre.g. GL.iNet; deduct if your home router already does WireGuard
3800 VA UPS3.600 krMDF, IDF-1, vault; NAS graceful shutdown
3Cabinets, patch panels, keystones, patch cords, labels, env. sensor3.000 krAs-built labels KF-01…36
1Fibre uplink kit (recommended)1.500 kr2 × duplex fibre + SFPs; replaces KF-20–23
1Contingency: 7th AP / PoE-to-USB-C / spare SFP1.000 krOnly used if survey/decisions require it
Hardware subtotal32.400 kr34.900 kr incl. fibre + contingency
30–36 hMy time @ 1.050 kr31.500–37.800 krSurvey, design, staging, 2 days onsite, Telia/Nets/alarm coordination, docs, training, first restore test
Turnkey targetca. 68.000 krRealistic range 64.000–72.000 kr ex moms

Not included: electrician cabling/230 V/ventilation, building works, Telia/Nets/alarm-company hardware or their subscriptions, Fysiojournal licences, ongoing monitoring, extra APs beyond the survey allowance, ISP charges. If the existing Synology must be replaced as primary, add ~2.200–3.500 kr.

Phase 1 if 40.000 kr is a hard cap: ~39.000–42.000 kr ex moms = gateway, main + first-floor PoE switches, 5 APs, VLANs/SSIDs/firewall, 2 UPS, 12–16 h of my time, reusing the Synology as-is. Not included: offsite NAS, home VPN, backup rebuild, restore test, tablet power survey, vault environmental work. I do not recommend stopping there, because Lars’ USB routine stays the only offsite copy.


7. Budget answer in one line

40.000 kr ex moms including my time is realistic only for a reduced Phase 1, not for the full move. For everything you described, approve ca. 68.000 kr ±10 % (plus the electrician separately), or approve Phase 1 now and schedule Phase 2 before summer when you go to 14 people.


8. What I need you to decide / clarify before I start

Please reply with ticks/answers; then I send the fixed quote and the final labelled drop list for week 3.

  1. Approve budget: ☐ ~68.000 kr turnkey ☐ Phase 1 ~40.000 kr ☐ please value-engineer. Confirm the electrician’s work is outside my quote.
  2. Vault: confirm 230 V, ventilation/heat removal, humidity, smoke/heat detector, landlord/fire approval and key access. If not, ☐ put primary NAS in MDF instead.
  3. Existing Synology: model, number of bays, disk sizes/RAID/SMART, DSM version, 1G/2.5G ports, current shares/permissions, and may I rebuild it? Approve 2 × 4 TB refresh?
  4. Offsite site: approve a small encrypted NAS + WireGuard router at your home; confirm home router subnet (must not be 10.47.x.x), home upload speed, and that encrypted clinic data may sit there. If not, nominate another offsite address.
  5. Retention: confirm backup version/retention policy for old journals and scans with your accountant/DPA; default = keep everything, no auto-delete.
  6. Tablets: 8 × 230 V/USB-C by electrician ☐ or PoE-to-USB-C adapters (+ports/budget) ☐. Tablet OS/MDM owner? Do tablets need to print? (Recommended: no.) Fysiojournal MFA enabled and any URL/IP allowlist?
  7. Printers: floor for each of the 2 printers + label printer; is label printer network or USB? Any scan-to-SMB/scan-to-email to the NAS?
  8. Telia: written config for the 6 phones — VLAN ID, DHCP options 66/120/160, SIP proxy, PoE 802.3af/at, codec, whether Telia’s router stays, and whether phones daisy-chain PCs. Confirm 3 ground / 3 upstairs.
  9. Nets: 2 terminal models, wired vs 4G fallback, PoE?, PSU, destination IP ranges/allowlist, static IP needs. Confirm both at front desk.
  10. Alarm company: final 4 camera locations (2/2 assumed), PoE standard/wattage, NVR location, cloud/Internet/static-IP needs, who changes default passwords, retention, databehandleraftale.
  11. Wi-Fi/auth: shared PSK ☐ or per-user WPA2-Enterprise via local RADIUS (+4 h, no licence) ☐; guest bandwidth cap OK? Approve no guest/tablet printing.
  12. Remote: approve WireGuard client on your laptop and on physio laptops only if they need old scans; confirm no QuickConnect / no exposed NAS ports; confirm laptop encryption + MFA.
  13. Throughput: is ~600–900 Mbit with IPS acceptable, or is full 1000/1000 with all security on mandatory (gateway upgrade, extra cost)?
  14. Dates/access: 1 February move — I need a 2-hour site survey before week 3, access for install in week 4, and a cutover window with Telia/Nets/alarm on site. Keep the old internet until the new site is tested.
  15. After handover: who patches devices / checks backups quarterly? ☐ Lars/you with my checklist ☐ optional fixed-price quarterly visit (not a subscription).

If you approve this draft and answer the above, I will convert it into a fixed quote and hand the electrician the final KF-01…KF-36 / P-01…P-08 schedule.

Venlig hilsen / best regards,
[Your name]
IT consultant
Draft v1.0 — for approval, not yet a fixed quote

Attempt 365.8 min44,274 tokens

Subject: Re: netværk?? – proposed network design for Krogh Fysio (for approval)

Hi Mette,

No need to apologise — English is fine, and thanks for the detail. It is enough to design this properly. I have written it so you can approve it and so the electrician/technician can build from it. Section 2 is the one to forward to the electrician before week 3.

Short answer: yes, 40.000 kr ex moms is realistic for the network equipment + my time — but only just, and only under the assumptions below. There are a few places where what you asked for has to be adjusted; I have put those first so they are not buried.


1. Things I have to flag before you approve
  1. The vault can hold the Synology, but not the “whole server thing”.
    The steel door and thick brick will block Wi‑Fi completely, and the fibre arrives at the front desk at the opposite end. So:
    • Router/firewall, main switch, Wi‑Fi controller and all PoE stay in a rack by the fibre inlet on the ground floor (GF‑01).
    • The existing Synology + UPS + a small switch go in the vault (B‑01), connected by wired fibre. No AP, no Wi‑Fi, no mobile signal in the vault.
    • Putting everything in the vault is technically possible, but means extending the WAN to the vault and running all 30+ cables down there: roughly +6.000–8.000 kr and a worse single point of failure. I do not recommend it and it breaks the 40.000 kr ceiling.
  2. “Off‑site backup” + “no more monthly subscriptions” cannot mean a cloud/datacentre copy.
    A managed cloud backup always has a recurring storage/egress charge. The no‑subscription way to get a proper automatic copy outside the building is: a small clinic‑owned, encrypted NAS at a second site — I suggest your home, since you work from there Thursdays — replicating from the vault over a WireGuard VPN.
    • If “not in the building” specifically means a datacentre, please approve a monthly line instead and I will re‑quote.
    • The old alternative (Lars + USB disk on Fridays, or rotating disks to a safe deposit box) is manual again, so I am not proposing it as the primary solution.
    • Because this is old patient data, I need your written OK to place an encrypted, clinic‑owned device in a private home. The backup is encrypted with a key held by the clinic, not stored on the NAS.
  3. Remote access with zero subscription only works if Fibia gives us a reachable public IPv4 / DDNS.
    Mette’s Thursday access and the home‑NAS replication use WireGuard hosted on our router (no licence, no QuickConnect, no Tailscale/free cloud relay for health data). If Fibia hands off behind CGNAT / double‑NAT with no public IP and no port forward/DMZ, inbound VPN cannot work. Then we need either a static public IP from Fibia or a paid tunnel/relay — i.e. a subscription. Please confirm this with Fibia before I order.
  4. Guest Wi‑Fi will have no printing exception.
    The waiting‑room kid printing incident is fixed by design: guest VLAN → Internet only, client isolation, no mDNS/AirPrint reflection, firewall drop to all printer/NAS/phone/camera/payment ranges. If reception needs to print something for a patient, it is printed from a front‑desk PC on the staff VLAN, not from the guest device.
  5. Telia, Nets and the alarm company must confirm their details before I can guarantee “keep working”.
    I will provide the ports, PoE, VLANs and QoS, but I will not guess SIP settings, card‑terminal allowlists or camera/NVR requirements. See the clarification list in section 8.
  6. Budget scope.
    I have assumed the electrician’s cable pulling, 230 V outlets, brick chasing and fire‑stopping are in the builder/electrician’s own quote, not in my 40.000 kr. If your 40.000 kr is meant to pay the electrician as well, it is not realistic — cabling alone in an old bank with thick walls can easily be 15.000–25.000 kr ex moms. My 40.000 kr covers network hardware + my configuration/cutover time, not building work.

2. Physical layout and cabling — for the electrician, week 3
Rooms / racks
IDLocationContentsPower
GF‑01Lockable 12U wall rack at/near front desk where Fibia terminatesFibia NT → firewall/router → 48‑port PoE+ core switch, Omada controller, patch panels, UPS1 dedicated 230 V circuit + UPS
B‑01Basement vault, small 6U shelf/cabinetExisting Synology, new/healthy disks, local USB backup disk, 8‑port switch with SFP, UPS1 dedicated 230 V circuit + UPS, ventilation/temperature < 30 °C
1FNo active equipment upstairsOptional passive consolidation panel only, no switch, no PSUNone

All horizontal cables home‑run to GF‑01. Every Cat6a run must be ≤ 90 m. If any first‑floor run is longer, stop and call me — do not use couplers. We then convert 1F to an active cabinet with a small PoE switch + UPS (+3.500–4.500 kr, outside the 40.000 kr unless you approve).

Cable schedule

All copper = solid‑copper Cat6a, S/FTP if run within 30 cm of mains, terminated on patch panels/keystones (no crimped plugs in walls), labelled both ends RK-GF-xx / RK-1F-xx / RK-B-xx. Provide as‑built with lengths + basic test report. Leave 2 m slack at outlets, 3 m at rack.

RefQtyFrom → ToTypePoEPatch / VLANNote
D01–D0333 front‑desk PCsCat6aNoVLAN 10Wired
D04–D0632 printers + label printerCat6aNoVLAN 10If label printer is USB‑only: omit D06, attach to D01
D07–D082Nets terminal 1 + 2Cat6aNo*VLAN 30*Enable PoE only if Nets confirms it
P01–P066Telia IP phones, assume 4 GF / 2 1FCat6a802.3af if confirmedVLAN 20Exact positions to be marked; Telia to confirm
AP‑GF‑01…0555 downstairs treatment roomsCat6a802.3atAP mgmt VLAN 60; SSIDs 10 + 50One AP per room. Tell me which new room is “room 3” — it gets its own AP regardless
AP‑GF‑061Waiting roomCat6a802.3atVLAN 60 / SSIDs 10 + 50Guest + staff
AP‑GF‑071GF corridor / staff areaCat6a802.3atVLAN 60 / SSID 10Staff laptops
AP‑1F‑01…0333 upstairs treatment roomsCat6a802.3atVLAN 60 / SSID 10
AP‑1F‑0411F corridor / staff areaCat6a802.3atVLAN 60 / SSID 10
C01–C044Cameras, positions by alarm companyCat6a802.3af/atVLAN 40Assume 3 GF / 1 1F; confirm
S‑1F‑01…022Upstairs spare data, staff room/officeCat6aNoVLAN 10, shutdownFuture
S‑GF‑01…022Reception/waiting sparesCat6aNoshutdownFuture
U‑FIB1GF‑01 SFP1 ↔ B‑01 SFP1Duplex OM3 or OS2 LC/LC fibre—Trunk: VLAN 60 + 70Primary vault uplink; fire‑stop penetration; no Wi‑Fi in vault
U‑CU1GF‑01 port 47 ↔ B‑01 switchCat6aNoshutdown standbyAdmin‑down. If route > 90 m, use a 2nd fibre pair instead
U‑RTR1Router LAN ↔ core switch port 48Patch cord in rackNoTrunk, native VLAN 60Not an electrician pull

Electrician total: 33 horizontal Cat6a + 1 standby Cat6a to vault + 1 duplex fibre (or 33 Cat6a + 2 fibre pairs if the standby copper would exceed 90 m). Plus dedicated 230 V at GF‑01 and B‑01. Do not pull fewer horizontal cables — extra capped ports are cheap, opening old brick walls again is not.

Switch port plan at GF‑01
  • 48‑port PoE+ switch, 384 W budget; calculated load ≈ 210 W (11 APs + 4 cameras + 6 phones).
  • Ports 1–36: endpoints above. PoE off on PCs/printers/Nets unless confirmed; PoE on for AP/camera/phone ports.
  • Port 47: standby vault copper, administratively down.
  • Port 48: trunk to router (native VLAN 60; allowed 10,20,30,40,50,60,70).
  • SFP1: fibre trunk to B‑01 (allowed VLAN 60 + 70 only). SFP2–4 spare.
  • Router WAN → Fibia NT in bridge/DMZ mode. Only inbound WAN rule: UDP 51820 WireGuard (+ ICMP/DDNS health). No port forwards to DSM, cameras, printers or phones.

3. Logical design / addressing

Proposed range: 10.30.0.0/16. If Fibia, Telia, your home LAN or Fysiojournal already use this, we switch the whole design to 10.47.0.0/16 instead — please confirm.

All VLAN gateways and firewall rules live on the router. Switches are Layer 2 only. DNS = the VLAN gateway; NTP via 10.30.60.2.

VLANNameSubnet / gatewayDHCPStatic / reservationsAccess
10Staff / Clinical10.30.10.0/24, gw .1.50–.200.21–.23 printers, .31–.33 front desk, .41–.48 wall tabletsInternet, Fysiojournal, printers, SMB/HTTPS to .70.10, VPN clients
20Voice (Telia)10.30.20.0/24, gw .1.50–.199Telia option 66/160 + DSCP EFTelia SIP/RTP subnets only; DHCP relayed to Telia router if they require it
30Payment (Nets)10.30.30.0/24, gw .1.50–.60.10–.12 terminalsNets FQDN/IP allowlist, DNS, NTP only
40Cameras10.30.40.0/24, gw .1.50–.60 reservations.5 NVR if supplied, .11–.14 camerasNVR, NTP, optional alarm‑company VPN; no Internet/staff/guest by default
50Guest10.30.50.0/24, gw .1.50–.200—DHCP/DNS/HTTP/HTTPS only; client isolation; ~50/50 Mbit per client; deny all RFC1918
60Management10.30.60.0/24, gw .1none.2 router, .3 core, .4 vault switch, .11–.30 APs, .31–.32 UPSIT admin + VPN only
70Storage / Backup10.30.70.0/24, gw .1none.10 vault SynologySMB/HTTPS from VLAN 10 + 80; initiates backup to home over WireGuard
80WireGuard VPN10.30.80.0/24no DHCP, /32 peers.1 clinic, .2 home router, .10–.50 remote laptopsSplit tunnel; home LAN 192.168.x.0/24 routed over tunnel
—WANFibia DHCP/static—Public IP / DDNSDeny all inbound except WireGuard

Firewall policy in one line per segment: Staff → Internet + Fysiojournal + printers + Synology; Guest → Internet only; Payment → Nets only; Cameras → NVR/NTP only; Voice → Telia only; Storage → backup peer + alerts only; Management/VPN → admin only. mDNS/AirPrint reflector is disabled toward VLAN 50, Wi‑Fi Direct disabled on printers, printer admin passwords changed. That is the printing fix.


4. Wi‑Fi
  • 11 wired Wi‑Fi 6 APs (8 treatment rooms + waiting room + GF corridor + 1F corridor), all PoE+ from GF‑01, adopted by a local controller (no cloud subscription).
  • No mesh/repeaters. Every AP has copper backhaul. Treatment room 3 gets its own AP; thick brick means a “stronger router” would not fix it.
  • Channel plan after a short site survey: 2.4 GHz on 1/6/11 at low power (10–14 dBm), 5 GHz channels staggered between floors, 802.11r/k/v enabled. Final power/channels documented in the runbook.
  • SSIDs:
    • KF‑Staff → VLAN 10, WPA2/WPA3‑PSK, staff laptops + 8 wall tablets. PSK rotated quarterly / on leaver. Tablets get DHCP reservations, kiosk/MDM, 2‑min auto‑lock, encryption, Fysiojournal MFA.
    • KF‑Guest → VLAN 50, WPA2‑PSK on a printed card at reception, client isolation, bandwidth cap, rotated monthly by reception/controller. No captive portal SMS/e‑mail, because that would be a subscription.
    • KF‑Terminals → hidden SSID, VLAN 30 + MAC allowlist, only if Nets terminals turn out to be Wi‑Fi only. Otherwise they stay wired.
    • No SSID in the vault.

5. Security, phones, payment, cameras, printers, patient data
  • Patient data: Fysiojournal stays cloud/HTTPS with MFA; the Synology holds the old journals/scans (~600 GB) and is treated as health data: SMB signing, no SMBv1, DSM MFA, auto‑block, audit logs, encrypted shares/backups, firmware updated, access by clinic groups. Your Fysiojournal data‑processing agreement remains yours to confirm — I am not giving legal GDPR advice, just building the technical controls.
  • Telia IP phones (6): VLAN 20, DSCP EF, PoE only if confirmed. We parallel‑run the Telia box until cutover and do not change SIP credentials. Need Telia’s VLAN/option 66/SIP proxy/IP ranges and written go‑live contact.
  • Nets (2): wired VLAN 30, outbound allowlist only. We segment, but cannot certify PCI compliance — need Nets’ segmentation/allowlist sheet.
  • Cameras (4): 4 PoE ports, VLAN 40, no Internet by default. We supply “a port and PoE”; recording/NVR/retention/remote viewing is the alarm company’s scope unless quoted.
  • Printers (2 + label): static 10.30.10.21–.23, reachable only from VLAN 10 (and optionally Mette’s VPN peer if you ask). Guest/payment/camera/voice cannot reach them.
  • Laptops/tablets: disk encryption, screen lock, no local journal copies, Fysiojournal MFA, lost‑device process = revoke that device’s WireGuard key + Fysiojournal session.

6. Backup and remote work
Backup — 3‑2‑1, no new subscription
  1. Copy 1: existing Synology in vault, 10.30.70.10. If its current disks are not healthy/redundant, add 2 × 4 TB NAS disks in RAID1/SHR. Btrfs snapshots if supported: 7 daily / 4 weekly / 12 monthly.
  2. Copy 2: 4 TB USB disk attached to the vault Synology, nightly Hyper Backup, stays in vault for fast restores.
  3. Copy 3 (off‑site): small encrypted Synology at your home (or Jonas’s office if you prefer), reached over a site‑to‑site WireGuard tunnel from the clinic router. Nightly Hyper Backup with client‑side AES‑256, versioning, integrity check, e‑mail alert to an existing clinic mailbox if a backup fails > 24 h. Lars no longer needs to remember Fridays.
  4. Home NAS is a read‑only backup target, not a live file server. For live files you connect to the vault Synology over VPN.
  5. If your home router already supports WireGuard, we use it; otherwise we add a small ~700 kr WireGuard router at home. Home CGNAT is fine (it initiates outbound); the clinic side still needs the public IP/DDNS from Fibia.
  6. RPO ≈ 24 h. Local restore ≈ 2–4 h for 600 GB; full restore from home over a typical home upstream can take 8–20 h, which is why the local USB copy stays in the vault. We do one test restore at go‑live and document a quarterly check.
  7. I am deliberately not using QuickConnect, Tailscale free tier or a cloud relay for health data.
Remote work
  • Mette, Thursdays: WireGuard client on your laptop → 10.30.70.10 (SMB/DSM), split tunnel so your home printer/Internet still work. DNS 10.30.60.2. No RDP, no inbound port forwards. Per‑device key, revocable.
  • Two physios on home visits: Fysiojournal directly over HTTPS/hotspot; no VPN needed unless they must open old scans, in which case same WireGuard client. MFA + encrypted devices + screen lock.
  • No new VPN licence, no controller subscription, no cloud backup subscription. Existing Fibia/Telia/Nets/Fysiojournal/alarm contracts stay as they are.

7. Equipment and rough costs (ex moms / ex VAT)

I have priced TP‑Link Omada because it has no licence fees and fits your ceiling. Equivalent UniFi is fine but costs more; see note below.

QtyItemPurposeEst. kr ex moms
1Omada ER707‑M2 or equivalent 2.5G WAN router with WireGuard, VLAN, DDNSFirewall, inter‑VLAN routing, VPN1.800
1Omada OC200 local hardware controllerAP/switch/guest control, no cloud sub800
1Omada TL‑SG2452P, 48 × GbE PoE+, 384 W, 4 SFPAll endpoints + router + spares4.500
1Omada TL‑SG2210P, 8 PoE + 2 SFP (vault)Vault switch, fibre uplink1.300
21G SFP LC transceivers + OM3/OS2 patchGF‑01 ↔ B‑01 fibre500
11Omada EAP610 Wi‑Fi 6 AP, PoE+8 rooms + waiting + 2 corridors9.900
12 × 4 TB NAS disks, RAID1 for existing Synology if current disks not healthy/redundantMain copy1.800
14 TB USB local backup diskFast local restore900
1Synology DS124 + 4 TB (or DS223j + 2 × 2 TB) off‑site targetEncrypted home backup2.700
1Small WireGuard router at home if home router cannot do WireGuardSite‑to‑site tunnel700
21.5 kVA line‑interactive UPS with USB monitoringGF rack + vault; PoE endpoints ride through GF UPS3.600
1 lot12U GF rack, 6U vault shelf, patch panels, keystones, labels, patch cords, fibre box, sundriesLabelled, serviceable install2.800
—My time: survey, 7 VLANs, 11 APs, firewall, VPN, backup, cutover, runbook, first restore test, handover (~10–12 h)Design + build + docs8.000

Total ≈ 39.300–39.500 kr ex moms. So yes: 40.000 kr is realistic, with ~500 kr slack, provided:

  • electrician/cabling/230 V is separate;
  • all Cat6a runs are ≤ 90 m;
  • we reuse healthy existing Synology disks or your home router already does WireGuard (each deducts ~700–1.800 kr if so);
  • no extra AP / no second upstairs switch is needed after survey.

I recommend approving 41.500 kr to include one contingency AP or a longer‑run uplift. If you need a hard 40.000 kr cap, say “hard cap” and I will not order anything extra without written approval.

Not included: electrician labour/cable/230 V/fire‑stopping, VAT/moms (25 %), Fibia NT changes, Telia phones/SIP, Nets terminals, cameras/NVR/recording, the 8 tablets, laptops, 3 front‑desk PCs, printers, any cloud backup, alarm‑company monitoring, ongoing patch/monitoring visits after handover. Prices are rounded ±10 % and final after a 1‑hour site survey.

Alternative if you prefer UniFi: UDM SE + USW‑48‑PoE + 11 × U6+ gives the same VLAN/VPN design, still no subscription, but ≈ 46.000–48.000 kr ex moms. It also gives deeper IPS/IDS at 1 Gbit; the Omada base design does stateful firewall + segmentation but no deep DPI. Tell me if you want that instead.


8. What I need you to decide / clarify before I start

Please reply before the electrician starts week 3 (ideally Friday of week 2). If something is “not sure”, give me the contact and permission and I will call Telia/Nets/alarm/Fibia myself.

  1. Approve: Option A (Omada), hard cap 40.000 kr or 41.500 kr with contingency, electrician separate, 10.30.0.0/16, 11 APs, Synology in vault only, router at GF‑01.
  2. Off‑site location: your home address, home router model + current LAN subnet (must not overlap 10.30.0.0/16), confirmation it is powered/on‑line, and written OK to store an encrypted clinic‑owned NAS with old patient data there. Who holds the backup encryption key, and what happens if you move/leave? If not home: Jonas/accountant office, or manual safe‑deposit rotation.
  3. Confirm the backup trade‑off: “no subscription + not in building” = home NAS, not datacentre. If you want datacentre/cloud, approve a monthly cost and I re‑quote.
  4. Fibia: handoff RJ45 or SFP, any WAN VLAN tag, bridge/DMZ mode, public static IPv4 or working DDNS, CGNAT yes/no, who owns the router. Needed for WireGuard.
  5. Telia: 6 phone models/MACs, exact positions on the plan, PoE or local PSU, VLAN/option 66/160, SIP proxy/IP ranges, whether their router/SBC must stay inline, cutover contact.
  6. Nets: wired or Wi‑Fi, PoE?, 2 positions, current allowed FQDN/IP ranges, PCI/segmentation sheet.
  7. Alarm company: 4 camera positions, 802.3af vs at, NVR location/IP, retention, remote‑access ports, who supplies recorder/cloud service.
  8. Printers: models, Ethernet vs Wi‑Fi, is the label printer USB‑only? Confirm we may disable Wi‑Fi Direct and change admin passwords.
  9. Tablets: 8 models/OS, Wi‑Fi only or PoE, who supplies/MDM/kiosk, Fysiojournal MFA, and which new room is “treatment room 3”. Not in my 40.000 kr.
  10. Existing Synology: model, bay count, current disks/RAID/health, DSM version, is the data share already encrypted, admin accounts, current USB disk. Can we reuse the disks?
  11. Home/remote: your home subnet, do you need clinic printers from home or only Synology, do the two physios ever need old scans or only Fysiojournal, laptop OS/disk‑encryption status, who revokes a lost device, and a mailbox for backup alerts.
  12. Vault: ventilation/temperature < 30 °C, 230 V, keys/access for service, confirmation that wired fibre only is OK and no router/AP goes in there.
  13. Electrician: marked floor plan with room numbers, ≤ 90 m rule, test report, fire‑stopped fibre penetration, dedicated circuits, week‑3 date, and a 30‑min call with me + electrician + alarm company if useful.
  14. Cutover: 1 February move window, parallel‑run period, sign‑off contact, after‑hours number.

If the marked plan is not ready in time, the electrician should still pull the full 33 Cat6a + fibre and leave slack; we patch/enable phone, camera and Nets ports only after confirmations. Do not reduce the cable count.


9. Approval block

Please reply with one line, for example:

Approved – Option A, 40.000 kr hard cap ex moms, electrician separate, off‑site NAS at my home, Synology in vault only, 11 APs, 10.30.0.0/16. Answers/contacts to follow.

Or:

Approved with 41.500 kr contingency / UniFi alternative / cloud backup re‑quote.

Then I will order hardware, send the electrician the final labelled cable schedule as a PDF, configure the VLANs/Wi‑Fi/VPN/backup, cut over before 1 February, run the first restore test and hand you a short runbook.

Best regards,
[Your name]
IT consultant

The prompt

Exactly what every model got

Read the full prompt

Prompt:

You are an IT consultant. A new customer sent the email below. Write the network design you would send back to her.

It should be something she can approve and a technician can build from: the layout and addressing, what equipment to buy and roughly what it costs, how Wi-Fi, security, backup and remote work are handled, and anything you need her to decide or clarify before you start. If something she asks for cannot be done the way she wants, say so.


From: Mette Krogh
Subject: netværk?? (sorry, writing in English since Jonas said you prefer that)

Hi,

Jonas from the accountants gave me your name. We are a physiotherapy clinic, Krogh Fysio, and we are moving on 1 February to a bigger place, two floors, ground floor and first floor, about 180 m2 each I think. Thick brick walls, it is an old bank building. There is a vault in the basement we want to use for the server thing, the door is steel.

Right now everything is just plugged into the box from the internet company and honestly it is a mess, the Wi-Fi drops in treatment room 3 all the time and last month a patient's kid was somehow printing from the waiting room?! That cannot happen. We have patient journals so I guess that matters.

We are 11 people now but will be 14 by summer, and 3 of those are front desk. Everyone has a laptop except front desk who have fixed PCs (3). There are 8 treatment rooms in the new place, 5 downstairs and 3 upstairs, each will have a tablet on the wall for the journal system (it is cloud, called Fysiojournal). We have 2 printers plus a label printer, the card terminal (Nets, there will be two at the new place), and the phones are those IP phones from Telia, 6 of them, they need to keep working. Oh and the alarm company is putting up 4 cameras and said they "need a port and PoE", no idea.

We have a Synology box with all our scanned documents and the old journals from before we went cloud, around 600 GB. At the moment the backup is a USB disk that Lars takes home on Fridays, when he remembers. I want a proper backup that is not in the building. But I do not want any more monthly subscriptions, we pay for too many things already.

Patients should have Wi-Fi in the waiting room. Two of the physios do home visits and write journals from the car, and I work from home Thursdays and need the Synology from there.

The fibre is 1000/1000 from Fibia and comes in on the ground floor by the front desk, which is the opposite end of the building from the vault stairs. The electrician is pulling cables in week 3 so he needs to know how many and where, he asked me and I said I would get back to him.

Budget: I was thinking 40.000 kr for all of it, ex moms, that includes your time. Is that realistic?

Mette


Grading

How this was graded

Opinion.

All nine plans

  • said the 40,000 kr budget only works if the electrician is paid separately
  • called out that off-site backup and no subscriptions conflict, and offered a second NAS at the owner's home
  • isolated the patient Wi-Fi so the printing incident cannot repeat

Differences noticed

  • Eight plans said yes if cabling is separate; one (full Hy4) said no and quoted about 68,000 kr with a reduced first phase at 40,000.
  • Two of Hy4 Flash's plans put the router in the vault at the far end from the fibre; the full Hy4 kept the router at the fibre.
  • The same model gave very different designs between attempts.
  • The box above counts eight yes-plans on the budget. One of them, Hy4 Flash attempt 3, says the budget is realistic if the electrician is separate and then totals 44,000–48,500 kr, which is why my verdict counts seven.
  • Opinion Some prices look low, for example six access points for 3,600 kr in one Hy4 Flash plan and 8,000 kr for all the consultant's time in one full Hy4 plan.
  • The two boxes above are observations noted before the verdict. Where they differ from the verdict, the verdict is my answer.

Each attempt started from a fresh state with a new seed. The answer limit was 60,000 tokens, thinking included. More on the method